Literary Criticism

Start Free Trial

What is traditional criticism?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

"Criticism" is the branch of literary study that defines, analyzes, interprets, and judges a work of literature according to various aesthetic systems.

The two main traditional Greek systems of criticism are Aristotelian and Platonic. Aristotelian criticism determines the value of a work according to its logical and formal qualities. That is, it is criticism of the work itself with no relation to other aspects of life. Platonic criticism determines the value of the work in relation to life. In theory, Aristotle's way is more objective and Plato's was more subjective. Both have influenced subsequent developments in theory and criticism in different ways.

That is generally where/when Western Literary Criticism and Theory is said to have begun. But a more modern concept of "traditional literary criticism" is the judging and defining of a literary canon. The canon is a group of literary works, selected by scholars, as the best representation of that country's (or community's) most valued literary works. A traditional American literary canon, for example, contains the likes of Hawthorne, Whitman, Emerson, Dickinson, Twain, Fitzgerald, and so on. With the rise of cultural theory (including feminism, race theory, deconstruction, and new historicism), the traditional canon has changed to include more works by female and minority writers, thus giving the canon a more accurate representation of American writers and culture.

Lastly, traditional literary criticism was more of a linear history of that canon. The canon and criticism became more "modern" with the inclusion of new writers as well as with the advent of those literary theories (such as deconstruction, new historicism, and post-structuralism) which assessed literary works using outside resources (such as psychoanalysis, language theories, and cultural theories).

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Criticism as a discipline and an approach to analyzing (and therefore appreciating) works of art has a long history in Western culture.  Traditional literary criticism before  the Chicago School of the mid-20th century involved establishing writer A's influence over writer B (Trollope's influence on Dickens, for example).  There is also the  critical question of "appropriateness" by which, in traditional criticism, is meant ethically or morally appropriate--a piece of literature that advocated inequality, for example, would be "criticized" by the Greeks.

Finally, traditional criticism was free from outside, or "hidden" agendas or slants.  One of the major contributions of deconstructive criticism is how it reveals hidden biases in the author.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team