What is the summary for A Shining Affliction: A Story of Harm and Healing in Psychotherapy?

Expert Answers
Lorraine Caplan eNotes educator| Certified Educator

Rogers' book is the story of her very first psychotherapy patient, five-year-old Ben, as well as the story of her own problems and her experiences as a patient in psychotherapy, both unsuccessful and successful. She records her thoughts and feelings about both "stories," learning, as the therapist and the patient, how each informs the other in complex ways.  

Ben, at the tender age of five, already has a troubled history. He has been diagnosed with "oppositional personality disorder." Since this book was published in 1995, this diagnosis might now be called oppositional defiant disorder (ODD.) Ben's biological mother deserted him and he has been in at least a few foster homes, the first having exposed him to severe neglect, which included his having spent most of his time in a crib, locked up in a room.  In fact, horrifyingly, he was found in his crib only after firefighters had evacuated the rest of the family from a fire in the house.

in the midst of Rogers' treatment of Ben, she has a mental breakdown, is hospitalized for a few months, and then gradually works her way back to mental health, functionality, and her therapy with Ben. She has had the experience of unsuccessful therapy with a woman she refers to as Melanie, an experience that likely contributed to her breakdown. Subsequently, she has therapy with Blumenthal, who helps her in innumerable ways, helping her understand how her own experiences and problems are an important part of her therapy with Ben.  Blumenthal helps her to navigate through to the end of her treatment of Ben and to navigate through to the completion of her own education and subsequent career. 

The book contains great insight into the rewards and risks of psychotherapy, the importance of our childhoods, and the richness and complexity of the psychotherapuetic relationship. 

write2meric eNotes educator| Certified Educator

This is an amazing book demonstrating the danger and potential of analytic psychotherapy. The fact that it is biographical makes it a very courageous account. The story begins with Dr. Annie Rogers finishing her training as a  therapist by working with Ben, a six-year-old boy who has been in various foster-placements where he has experienced grave neglect. She uses a technique called play therapy to establish rapport with him. At the same time she is seeing a student-analyst for therapy. In the process of this, issues of her own early childhood traumas emerge; this leads to a mental breakdown. One feels that the student-analyst's failure to grasp what is happening with her patient and the subsequent unsuccessful treatment (Rogers comes to therapy with a gun and a knife) contribute to the breakdown.

After regaining some sanity, Rogers finds Dr. Blumenthal, an older and wiser analyst who is able to help her understand what happened in the failed therapy and in her own childhood. She is able to come back to mental stability and to return to school and to working with Ben.

Issues of abandonment come up for both Dr. Rogers and Ben as they struggle to overcome their respective traumas. Dr. Blumenthal is able to remain unfazed by his patient's acting out her emotions, which contributes to her return to health. She demonstrates this same quality in her work with Ben, which takes him a good way toward health and a good relationship with his new adoptive family.

Access hundreds of thousands of answers with a free trial.

Start Free Trial
Ask a Question