What satire can we find in part 4 of Gulliver's Travels? How does it criticize society?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

I would suggest that the fourth part of Gulliver's Travelscontains a criticism of the rationalism the Enlightenment espoused. Indeed, it's worth keeping in mind that Jonathan Swift himself could be quite critical of the Enlightenment and its focus on reason, as can be seen in a work such as...

See
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

I would suggest that the fourth part of Gulliver's Travels contains a criticism of the rationalism the Enlightenment espoused. Indeed, it's worth keeping in mind that Jonathan Swift himself could be quite critical of the Enlightenment and its focus on reason, as can be seen in a work such as "A Modest Proposal." That particular pamphlet seemed to suggest that reason on its own (unsupported by empathy and genuine human emotion) can lead one down paths that are utterly monstrous. I'd suggest this same perspective seems to be at work in the episode of the Houyhnhnms.

As has already been expressed, much of the satire of this fourth book depends on the reversal between the humanoid yahoos (who are treated within the narrative as beasts) and the hyper-rational Houyhnhnms. However, while Gulliver certainly idolizes the Houyhnhnms, that extreme rationalism contains an emotional coldness that turns into cruelty. Thus, we can observe in chapter 9 these hyper-rational horses holding a debate concerning the proposed extermination of the Yahoos.

Later, in chapter 10, Gulliver himself faces rejection by the Houyhnhnms. Readers of Gulliver's Travels must often differentiate between Gulliver's opinions and Swift's own opinions, which can often conflict with one another. I'd suggest that such a tension may well be in effect with Gulliver's time among the Houyhnhnms.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In Book Four, Gulliver travels to the land of the Houyhnhnms, morally upright, reasonable, talking horses. The Houyhnhnms rule over the savage, human-like Yahoos, which resemble Gulliver and other Europeans. Through Gulliver's interactions with the Houyhnhnms, Swift satirizes the European belief that humans are morally superior beings, who are ruled by dignified, honorable governments. Gulliver has several conversations with his Houyhnhnm master in which he attempts to explain European culture. However, Gulliver's master cannot comprehend many of the ills that plague European society. Gulliver's Houyhnhnm master has difficulty understanding Gulliver's description of the numerous vices inherent in mankind because there are no words for those wicked exploits in their country.

In chapter 5 of Book Four, Gulliver has another conversation with his Houyhnhnm master, in which he attempts to describe the nature of European war. Gulliver begins by describing the ridiculous, petty reasons European aristocrats go to war, then proudly describes the weapons used to slaughter thousands of enemies. Gulliver's description appalls the Houyhnhnm, and Gulliver mentions,

"But as my discourse had increased his abhorrence of the whole species, so he found it gave him a disturbance in his mind to which he was wholly a stranger before" (Swift, 314).

Swift once again satirizes the European belief that humans are morally superior beings through the reaction of Gulliver's Houyhnhnm master, who finds it utterly detestable that a Yahoo claiming to be reasonable could inflict such destruction upon other Yahoos.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In Part 4, Gulliver finds himself in the land of the Houyhnhnms, who are intelligent and moral horses. He at first believes the horses are owned by humans, but then he realizes that the horses are their own masters. On the other hand, the Yahoos, who are human-like characters, live like animals and are nasty brutes.

This chapter satirizes humans' sense of moral superiority. For example, Gulliver's Houyhnhnm master says:

"I understand you well...it is now very plain, from all you have spoken, that whatever share of reason the Yahoos pretend to, the Houyhnhnms are your masters; I heartily wish our Yahoos would be so tractable."

The horse believes that even in Gulliver's European world, the horses are superior and that the humans, or Yahoos, only pretend to have reason (which they clearly lack).

In addition, the Houyhnhnms are so moral that they make humans seem like brutes. Gulliver states:

"And I remember, in frequent discourses with my master concerning the nature of manhood in other parts of the world, having occasion to talk of lying and false representation, it was with much difficulty that he comprehended what I meant, although he had otherwise a most acute judgment."

In other words, the Houyhnhnms don't even understand what lying and falsehood are. Their morality makes humans seem deceitful and inferior in contrast. While humans clearly believe in their own superiority, this section suggests that they are inferior. By extension, this part of Gulliver's Travels satirizes Europeans' notions of superiority and their sense that people in the rest of the world are brutes. Instead, Swift suggests that Europeans are brutes and that their sense of superiority is unfounded.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In many ways, the satire is a very simple one in this case.  The Yahoos are meant to represent the general condition of the human race.  As Gulliver comes to understand, these beings are so incredibly selfish and so driven to vice and disgusting behavior, that any time they gain an advantage or find a way to get more resources, etc., they immediately turn that windfall or that gain into a further journey into vice.

By contrast, he makes it clear that the Houyhnhms are so incredibly rational.  So much of what they do makes great sense, etc.  Of course Gulliver tries as hard as he can to make himself into the latter and avoid interaction with or implication that he is in fact the former.

This satirical treatment of the human race is only strengthened by later parts of the story when Gulliver returns home and voices his disgust with the behavior of the people he interacts with.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team