What are the religious themes from "A Good Man is Hard to Find" by Flannery O'Connor?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

As far as this particular story is concerned, I think it centers around themes of sin and grace. These are two of the central themes of Christian teachings: that the world is in some way fallen but that salvation is possible through God's grace (enacted in Christ's sacrifice on the...

See
This Answer Now

Start your subscription to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Start your Subscription

As far as this particular story is concerned, I think it centers around themes of sin and grace. These are two of the central themes of Christian teachings: that the world is in some way fallen but that salvation is possible through God's grace (enacted in Christ's sacrifice on the cross), and in this fashion, humanity's fallen nature can be redeemed. O'Connor's story, and that of the grandmother in particular, express both of these core elements in Christian teaching.

First, as other contributors have noted, the grandmother herself is, for all her pretensions towards religiosity and respectability, vain, judgmental, prideful, and racist. When viewed within the language of Christian theology, these unpleasant attributes point towards her own fallen nature. However, as the story ends, facing death at the hands of the Misfit, she has a momentary epiphany, recognizing the essential humanity of the Misfit himself. In the process, she experiences a moment of grace. Within Christian teaching, grace and sin are intertwined with one another, and this is a vision reflected in the grandmother herself.

In addition, you can probably discuss the moral nihilism of the Misfit himself, which is itself shaped within a distinctly religious framework: for the Misfit, the continued viability of morality in and of itself comes down to the question of whether Christianity is or is not true. Either Christianity is true (in which case morality is real and ought to be followed) or Christianity is false (in which case everything collapses). This moral nihilism is thus founded within a context of Christian moral realism, and in this respect, it also has a religious dynamic should not be underestimated or ignored.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The story seems to convey the ideas that it is perfectly reasonable to question religion and that blind acceptance doesn't make a person a good one. The Misfit feels that Jesus "'thown everything off balance'" by accepting such a monumental punishment when Jesus had done nothing wrong. Now, in his own life, the Misfit has been forced to endure a massive punishment for a crime he did not commit, and he feels that it is Jesus's fault. He's been accused of murdering his father, and though "'they had the papers'" on him, he knows that his father died of the influenza. God doesn't inspire him because he blames God for his problems. The Misfit is obviously a frightening criminal, but he does demonstrate a kind of logic: that his punishment hasn't fit his crimes, and so he commits more crimes in order to make them balance. Despite his psychopathy, we likely find ourselves sympathizing with him in a way that we do not with the grandmother (who seems reprehensible in her own special way).

The grandmother seems to be a woman who would claim that she has religion, and yet she's a terrible racist who constantly judges other people and looks down on people like the Misfit when it is elitists like her who are responsible for his history. She's not a good person, despite her insistence that she is able to identify good people, and her religious belief has done nothing to make her feel more compassion or empathy for others. She may claim to be religious, but she hasn't thought through or internalized what Jesus would really want her to do.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

"A Good Man is Hard to Find" illustrates the Christian concept that anyone can be the recipient of God's grace at any time.

The difficult, childish, racist, classist, foolish, and self-centered Grandmother is one of the last people one would expect to be touched by God's divine love. Further, the circumstances under which she experiences it are grotesque and extreme.

The Grandmother is facing the Misfit, the man responsible for the murder of the rest of her family. He is about to kill her. She is desperately trying to reach him in the hope he might spare her life. He is a person she should hate and fear, as he has taken her loved ones from her and now threatens her life. Yet in the moment before he blows her away, she truly sees him as one of her own children. She sees him as God sees him, as a beloved child. Therefore, she dies in a state of grace and love; she has loved her enemy.

O'Connor is making the point that God's grace is available to all people at all times, even in the most dire or unexpected circumstances. When all the externals are stripped away and the Grandmother can no longer rely on her family, her money, or her status as a "lady," God's love is able to penetrate her heart. This expresses another Christian theme: that we are most open to the divine presence when we are most vulnerable.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The Christian ideal of God's grace is a central theme in Flannery O'Connor's "A Good Man is Hard to Find."  Despite being the worst, most unlikable characters in the entire story, the grandmother and the Misfit are shown to be recipients of God's grace, receiving his forgiveness and mercy despite their unworthiness.  In many ways, it is fitting that O'Connor choose the most unlikely characters to find grace at the end of the novel, because the grandmother and the Misfit are the least deserving.  Constantly complaining and picking on the other family members, the grandmother sours the entire family outing.  The Misfit is a homicidal maniac, but both experience experience God's grace before the end of the story.

When the grandmother declares "Why you're one of my babies!  You're one of my own children" to the Misfit at the very end, she does so because she finally makes the connection between the two of them, that they are all sinners in need of forgiveness.  In this moment of epiphany, the grandmother finds grace and understanding. The Misfit has his own moment of truth as well, realizing that there was no more pleasure to be found in murder; he may also find redemption.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team