Social Sciences

Start Free Trial

What are the negative results of internationalism, and what are some case studies in which internationalism has been unsuccessful?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

A naïve internationalism can have many negative unintended consequences.

Relocation of American plant and technology to China and China's consequent economic expansion have allowed a one-party authoritarian government to engage in a massive military build-up, threatening the security and autonomy of other regional powers.

The lack of environmental and labor standards in China has led to environmental destruction and high cancer rates among Chinese workers. Americans talk on iPhones partly made by desperate Chinese workers surrounded by suicide nets in a country where slave labor is widespread.

Economists promoting NAFTA forecast that it would strengthen the Mexican economy and cut illegal immigration as Mexicans would find more jobs in their own country. Instead, an avalanche of cheap agricultural exports from the United States wiped out Mexican peasant farming and increased the number of desperate migrants seeking work in the United States. This places additional burdens on schools, hospitals, and welfare systems already under tremendous stresses, and it places downward pressure on wages for America's most vulnerable.

Negative results of internationalism include hot money flows where speculative risk capital seeking high returns rush into emerging markets only to be rapidly withdrawn when the mood changes, resulting in chaos in global currency markets and industrial output.

Because internationalism favors large mobile international capital, it tends to weaken the bargaining power of national politicians and the people they represent. The gains of globalization have mostly flowed to the top, while the job losses and economic crises have most negatively affected the most economically vulnerable. Internationalism has increased the gap between rich and poor in the United States to levels not seen since the Gilded Age.

The savings glut in China and their recycling of capital into U.S. Treasury bonds allowed the Federal Reserve to stimulate the economy with artificially low interest rates leading to a massive misallocation of capital into non-productive, speculative assets, like domestic real estate, rather than productive assets.

When these asset bubbles burst, politicians bail out the banks that facilitated them at public expense (public losses, private gains) while small businesses (that didn't cause them go bankrupt) struggle. Economic mobility consequently has stagnated as small businesses have borne the brunt of economic dislocations caused by the globalists and their speculations.

Political instability has been the result in America and Europe as citizens increasingly view their politicians as captive servants of the globalist international financial elite.

A recent study by the National Bureau of Economic Research has shown that the negative effects on employment by the relocation of whole industries to foreign countries can have profound and lasting negative employment effects on whole regions from which the industries were uprooted.

New publications in international trade theory have shown that, although much of international trade results in positive-sum gains, sometimes these gains are highly asymmetric, and sometimes they can be negative-sum from the standpoint of a nation competing with other nations for the retention of key industries. Because of this, some international trade can be shown harmful to the long-run national interest....

This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

This is particularly true in the case of technology transfers in key industries.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In modern times, Internationalism  most commonly means an appreciation for the diverse cultures in the world, and a desire for world peace. Proponents of Internationalism believe in the interconnectedness of mankind, that man is not only a citizen of his country but of the world. Because of this view, Internationalists desire to help the world through leadership and charity. This leadership and charity can take the form of international organizations such as The World Health Organization, The United Nations, and the European Union, which was formed in order to consolidate economies and help all European nations succeed by cooperating together.

In American history, the United States started out being anti-Internationalist. In the Monroe Doctrine, for example, the Americans basically told the world, "You stay out of our affairs and we will stay out of yours." This worked for awhile. Today, however, the world is shrinking. Countries are so intertwined with other countries due to economies, trade, alliances, etc., that it is really, really hard to maintain neutrality. Very few countries have succeeded - Switzerland, being one of the few. That is why countries put their money in Swiss banks in time of war...........but I digress.

Case studies of where Internationalism has been unsuccessful - this would be a matter of opinion, but some people believe The United Nations has been totally ineffective. They are always issuing decrees and imposing sanctions that have no effect on stopping countries like North Korea for doing whatever they want and sticking their tongues out at the United Nations.

Right now, for example, my son is on a Navy ship monitoring the situation in the South China Sea because in spite of warnings by the United Nations FOR YEARS AND YEARS, the North Koreans recently blew up a South Korean submarine, then lied about it and said they did not do it, and if South Korea takes any retaliatory action, it will mean war. The United Nations is having a conference about this, while the U.S. Navy is actually doing something. I know, I'm biased.

If you do some research, you can find other examples of what similar International organizations have accomplished and then make up your own mind.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team