How does The Merchant of Venice illustrate the theme of appearance versus reality?

5 Answers | Add Yours

ishubert's profile pic

ishubert | High School Teacher | (Level 1) Adjunct Educator

Posted on

The theme of appearance versus reality is prevalent in The Merchant of Venice. One of the ways to examine this is by looking at the relationships between many of the characters in the play. Most obvious is Portia's disguise and subsequent interactions with the gentlemen of the court, in order to save her suitor's friend Antonio from Shylock's wrath in collecting his bond. Another example is the appearance of Jessica's devotion to her father Shylock, which is underscored by her desire to flee his grasp. The manner in which she accomplishes this, coupled with what she does once she has, highlights this theme.

There are other more subtle instances of appearance versus reality as well. Towards the end of the play Portia and Nerissa are complicit in a scheme to test their new relationships with Bassanio and Graziano. Also, Antonio's willingness to enter into a bond with Shylock, a man he despises, on the surface appears to be done out of freindship. Another possible interpretation is that Antonio is trying to live vicariously through the exploits of his younger  companions and gain entry to the life promised by Belmont.

gbeatty's profile pic

gbeatty | College Teacher | (Level 1) Educator Emeritus

Posted on

To address the question of how the Merchant of Venice deals with the theme of appearance versus reality, start by reviewing the play. To be specific, look at the following things:

Look at how Antonio acts towards Shylock when talking directly to him, versus how he acts when Shylock can't hear him.

Then do the same for Shylock. What does he say privately, versus publicly?

Then, consider Portia. She dresses up like a man, changing her appearance, in order to change reality. Look at that section.

Then look at the discussions of the laws. What do they mean--and what are they interpreted to mean?

Then look at which chest is considered the right choice, versus which one different people choose. There is a conflict there between appearance and reality.

Remember this line from the play: All that glisters is not gold.

krish2606's profile pic

krish2606 | eNotes Newbie

Posted on

tell me the dialogues which shows appearance vs reality in merchant of venice
jaytay2's profile pic

jaytay2 | Student, Grade 10 | eNotes Newbie

Posted on

In the play, this theme comes in the form of deception, lies and disguise.  In the casket plot, the choosing of the caskets looks simple, and dependent upon luck, or chance. When In actuality it tests the intelligence and character of the suitor. In the bond plot, Shylock appears to be friendly with Antonio when he actually has an underhanded objective, which is to take one pound of flesh anywhere from Antonio’s body that he pleases. And in the ring plot, Portia and Nerissa disguise themselves as men in order to attend the trial. 

Sources:
dk3006's profile pic

dk3006 | High School Teacher | (Level 2) eNoter

Posted on

Appearance versus reality would not be one of the dominant themes in this play. It would be more prevalent in plays such as Hamlet. However the one area that does have traces of this theme is the prejudice of the christains. Shylock has been forced under by the laws of venice for so many years, he has not even allowed to participate in trade because of his faith. Th one time he uses and follows the laws of venice to the letter a loophole is found. This shows that their is one laws for Christains and one law for Jews. This shows the theme of Apperance versus reality. 

We’ve answered 318,996 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question