What is the main idea of the "The Tell-Tale Heart"?

Expert Answers
kmj23 eNotes educator| Certified Educator

Arguably, the main idea of "The Tell-Tale Heart" is that when you commit a crime, like murder, you cannot escape your guilty conscience, no matter what the circumstances or your state of mind. Take the narrator's motivations, for example. He believes wholeheartedly that the old man he lives with has an "evil eye." This eye bothers him so much that it makes his blood run cold. The idea of murder is so strong in the narrator's mind that it "haunted" him day and night, and, more importantly, he believes that it is the only way of escaping this evil eye.

In terms of the murder itself, the narrator goes to great lengths to dispose of the old man's body and to evade detection by the authorities. Even when the police visit the house, the narrator has no problem convincing them of his innocence.

The sound of the beating heart, however, is so powerful that the narrator cannot ignore it. This sound functions as a symbol of his guilty conscience. Despite his dedication to not being caught by the police, the narrator is powerless to ignore this sound. He is literally deafened by the sound of his internal sense of guilt.

Through the experience of the narrator, then, Poe argues that guilt is not only a strong emotion but one that overpowers all others.

mlsldy3 eNotes educator| Certified Educator

In "The Tell-Tale Heart," we see that the narrator has some sort of issue with his mentality. He explains why he thought he had to kill his elderly roommate. The short story explores the human psyche. We are drawn into the mind of a madman. We get a rare glimpse into how someone with a mental problem reacts to certain things. The narrator believes that his roommate, who has an eye condition that makes one eye gray and cloudy, is giving him the evil eye, and that he can see into the narrator's soul. The narrator even tells the reader from the beginning of the story that he has some kind of mental problem.

"TRUE!-NERVOUS-VERY, very dreadfully nervous. I had been and am; but why will you say that I am mad?"

Edgar Allan Poe was a master at suspense. He takes a tale about a man who is mentally unstable and takes us for a ride into madness. The main idea of the short story is how mental illness can make someone so unstable that they are unable to stop the madness in their own minds.

amymc eNotes educator| Certified Educator

While seemingly a simple story, this Poe classic says a lot about the human mind.  For the most part, the narrator reveals the role that guilt can play.  He kills the old man because his eye bothers him, but the fictitious sound of a dead man's heartbeat is what dooms him.  His guilt is manifest by this heartbeat and leads him to reveal the body and his own crime to the authorities.  Basically, a person cannot escape his own guilty conscience; it will make itself evident somehow.