What literary elements in The Great Gatsby by Fitzgerald or The Kite Runner by Hosseini prove that "literature reveals what is bad in human nature?"I have to write an essay explaining the quote,...

What literary elements in The Great Gatsby by Fitzgerald or The Kite Runner by Hosseini prove that "literature reveals what is bad in human nature?"

I have to write an essay explaining the quote, “Literature opens a dark window on the soul, revealing more about what is bad in human nature than what is good.”

Expert Answers
lmetcalf eNotes educator| Certified Educator

This is a great quote and a great prompt to use in writing about a lot of classic and contempory works of literature.  Most characters in literature have a fatal flaw that causes or contributes to the conflict(s) in the story, and there is where you can start to look for what bad elements of human nature are revealed.  In The Great Gatsby you need to look all of the main characters and look at their flaws -- it isn't too hard!  Tom Buchanan, Daisy Buchanan, and even Jay Gatsby are very flawed people.  Tom is an arrogant, lying, philanderer.  Daisy is a shallow, lying, murderer.  Gastby is a criminal who doesn't have his head grounded in reality.  Those few adjectives are only the start of a description of these characters!  All of the worst elements of their natures collide in the course of this novel to create the story of Jay Gatsby and his tragic pursuit of Daisy and his untimely death.  Tom and Daisy are careless with each other and other people's lives.  Gastby is lost in a fantasy of Daisy that was never real and is certainly not acheivable now.  No matter what good you can say about any of these characters, their flaws overwhelm the goodness, thus proving the quote to be true.

The situation is different with Amir in The Kite Runner in that he ultimately does take actions that redeem his earlier failures, but the novel is driven by Amir's guilt and his trying to live down his past actions.  The novel looks squarely at Amir as a child who taunts his friend Hassan because their social standing allows for that behavior.  The novel pivots on the key scene of Hassan's being raped and Amir doing nothing then or later to help.  Amir's whole life, up until the day he returns to Afganistan to get Sohrab out of the clutches of the Taliban, is about his trying to live down that act of cowardice.  The novel studies the aftermath of what is bad in Amir's nature, but it has a more positive end in that Amir is able to take positive action and show an aspect of his human nature that is caring and brave. 

It usually seems that the important literature is tragic and reveals the bad of human nature -- probably because we learn more from our negative experiences than we do from the good ones.

Read the study guide:
The Great Gatsby

Access hundreds of thousands of answers with a free trial.

Start Free Trial
Ask a Question