What is the juxtaposition at the end of Book 2, Chapter 1 of 1984 by George Orwell?

Expert Answers
shake99 eNotes educator| Certified Educator

In this section of 1984 George Orwell is juxtaposing two relationships: the relationship of Winston and Julia with the relationship of Winston and the prisoner. 

In a sense, everyone in Oceania is a prisoner. They are all terrified of the Thought Police and under constant surveillance. One of the goals of the Party and Big Brother is to prevent people from forming meaningful relationships with one another—they want the only relationship people to value is their relationship with the Party.

Winston and Julia are taking a great risk by engaging in their secret (or so they think) affair. They succeed in conducting the clandestine affair for a while, but they have to be so careful that they are really still imprisoned in a way—they must hide and sneak around.

At the point when they see the prisoner they are in the open and afraid to even look each other in the eyes—it might give them away. They can, however, look at the prisoner without fear.

At this point the juxtaposition becomes ironic (irony is something surprising or unexpected). The final lines of the chapter are:

. . . they stared steadily in front of them, and instead of the eyes of the girl, the eyes of the aged prisoner gazed mournfully at Winston out of nests of hair.

Because of Orwell’s juxtaposition, the reader is mentally making a comparison of Winston/Julia with the prisoner/Winston. Here’s the irony involved—Winston and Julia cannot look each other in the eye, but the prisoner is able to look Winston in the eye. The word “mournfully” implies a certain degree of emotional honesty: the prisoner is the only character in this scene who is able to react without fear of detection; he doesn’t have to hide his emotions like Winston and Julia. In a way, the prisoner has more freedom than they do.

teachersage eNotes educator| Certified Educator

In this section, Winston and Julia meet anonymously in Victory Square, which is jammed full of people watching a convoy of war prisoners pass by. Orwell juxtaposes the prisoners, a symbol of war, dehumanization and domination, a potent, naked display of the state's power over human life, with the opposite: the nascent, very human and mutually supportive love relationship just barely beginning between Winston and Julia. The contrast could hardly be more jarring. At the same time, the juxtaposition unequivocally contextualizes the affair. Julia and Winston, in reality, will end up no more free than the prisoners they watch pass. They too are hemmed in by a repressive, dehumanizing culture that means to destroy them just as it means to destroy the prisoners filing by in army vehicles. 

Winston holds Julia's hand but doesn't dare turn his head to look into her eyes. Juxtaposed against this are the eyes of the prisoner he stares into instead, foreshadowing his own future as a helpless prisoner of the state.

pohnpei397 eNotes educator| Certified Educator

There are two juxtapositions I see at the end of this chapter.

  • Winston feels that he knows Julia's hand really well -- so well that he could know it if he saw it -- but he doesn't even know what color her eyes are.
  • Winston and Julia are holding hands, but instead of looking into Julia's eyes, he is looking into the eyes of the prisoner.

The first of these shows us how much Winston and Julia have to hide what they're doing.  The second is symbolic of their status in society.  It's saying that even though they are trying to fight back (by holding hands and having their affair) they are really just prisoners like the guy on the truck.