What is the image of "The Man with the Hoe"?

Jean-François Millet’s painting, Man With a Hoe, depicts an exhausted peasant man working in a field. It was meant to highlight the plight of the working class and was considered very controversial at the time. Inspired by this painting, Edwin Markham wrote the poem “The Man with the Hoe.” Markham’s poem describes a hopeless laborer who is treated more like a beast than a human being.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The poem "The Man With the Hoe" by Edwin Markham is based on a painting called L'homme a la houe by the French painter Jean-Francois Millet. The painting, which now resides at the J. Paul Getty Museum, depicts a man laboring in a rocky field overgrown with thistles. Bowed down by the effort of his toil, he is filthy and exhausted. His mouth is open, and he has a blank look on his face, as if the backbreaking work has left him dull and emotionless. First exhibited in 1863, the painting provoked controversy at the time because of its depiction of the brutal life to which peasants were subjected.

Using this painting as inspiration, Edwin Markham wrote "The Man With the Hoe." The poet gave a public reading of it on December 31, 1898, and it was then published in the San Francisco Examiner and subsequently many other newspapers in January 1899.

The poem starts off with a quote from Genesis that states that God made man in his own image. This is intended to contrast with the image of man presented in the poem as empty of expression, dead to emotion, and bowed down by the intolerable weight of his labor. Markham describes this poor man—who is supposedly made in the image of God—as a "slave of the wheel of labor," a "dread shape," and a "monstrous thing" that is "distorted and soul-quenched." This man can no longer appreciate the beauty of the stars, the light of dawn, the redness of a rose, or the melody of a song.

Markham calls upon the "masters, lords and rulers in all lands" to correct this image, straighten the man's shape, and give him back the music and dreams that define the true image of humanity.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Markham depicts a man in his poem "The Man with the Hoe" who works the land in an exhausted state--so exhausted, in fact, that he is "brother to the ox." The man at the center of Markham's poem lives much the way a beast of burden would, as he is constantly working and never able to take time to think or to ponder the marvels of the universe.

Markham was inspired to write the poem by the painting L'homme à la houe by Jean-François Millet. This painting, painted in 1860-1862, was controversial when it was shown at the Salon of 1863. It was considered too socialist in its message. The image is of a man whose facial features have been blotted out, obscuring his individuality. Wearing a loose-fitting white tunic, he leans against his hoe in a posture indicating exhaustion. He is working the desiccated land, which is rocky and infertile. The land is brown, and nothing green is growing. In the background, brush fires smolder, suggesting a land that is dried up and unable to yield crops. 

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

There are two answers to this question--two related answers, that is.

The first is that in this poem Edwin Markham is responding to a painting:

“L’homme à la houe” by Jean-François Millet, which means "man with a hoe." You can see this image at the Getty Museum, or via its website. (There's a link below.) In that original painting, you can see that the man with the hoe is tired. He's using the hoe, but he's also leaning on it. His mouth is open, like he's been working hard and needs to pant to catch his breath. While there are other people in the distance, this man is essentially working along.

The second image is the one described in the poem, which goes into more detail and offers specific interpretation. Markham describes things that aren't literally visible, like the first line "Bowed by the weight of centuries..." (How do you show centuries, rather than a tired person?) Markham's literal description is the same: the man, bent over the hoe, mouth open, tired from work. But he adds context, so that most of the poem is actually a political and philosophical argument.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team

We’ll help your grades soar

Start your 48-hour free trial and unlock all the summaries, Q&A, and analyses you need to get better grades now.

  • 30,000+ book summaries
  • 20% study tools discount
  • Ad-free content
  • PDF downloads
  • 300,000+ answers
  • 5-star customer support
Start your 48-Hour Free Trial