What is the difference between Miss Marple and Inspector Craddok in A Murder is Announced?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

There is a long tradition of British detective stories featuring gifted amateurs or "consulting detectives" whose successes are more spectacular than those of the police force. Sherlock Holmes runs rings around Inspector Lestrade, and Hercule Poirot does the same with Inspector Japp.

The relationship between Miss Marple, the amateur who...

Unlock
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Start your 48-Hour Free Trial

There is a long tradition of British detective stories featuring gifted amateurs or "consulting detectives" whose successes are more spectacular than those of the police force. Sherlock Holmes runs rings around Inspector Lestrade, and Hercule Poirot does the same with Inspector Japp.

The relationship between Miss Marple, the amateur who has made an acute study of human nature, and Inspector Craddock, the professional who uses the superior resources at his disposal with intelligence and discretion, is more sophisticated. Her intuition complements his methodical approach. Craddock is no "Scotland Yard bungler" but a highly competent police officer who respects Miss Marple and views her sharp mind as one of the resources at his disposal. Miss Marple reciprocates Craddock's respect and realizes that the police force will have an advantage over even the most gifted amateur in some procedural matters.

Although the frail, upper-middle-class old lady and the professional policeman apparently have very little in common, their complementary talents make them excellent partners.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Inspector Craddock is a professional law enforcement official and Miss Marple is an amateur sleuth. Craddock is also the godson of one of Miss Marple's friends.

Inspector Dermot Craddock is a detective for Scotland Yard. In A Murder is Announced, he seeks the help of Miss Jane Marple to solve the case. Although Inspector Craddock appears to be a good detective, he uses conventional methods to solve cases. Miss Marple, on the other hand, uses her keen observation skills and her knowledge of human nature to solve crimes.

Miss Marple has no formal training. Most of what she knows she learned from watching other people throughout her life. It's common for her to notice something that reminds her of the past and use that connection to solve crimes. Inspector Craddock decides to work with her when he sees what happened and doesn't believe that it's a suicide or an accident. They work together to discover the truth.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Unlike the bumbling and sometimes conceited police inspectors who can act as foils to Christie's star sleuths, Inspector Craddock is portrayed as very competent. He is described as having "brains and imagination" and the self-discipline to move slowly and carefully, as well as an "open mind." Craddock is a good partner to work with Miss Marple.

Craddock has police know-how and authority, along with resources to go to places like Scotland to see Belle. However, what Miss Marple has is an easy manner over the lunch and tea table, which draws people into confiding in her. She also is quick to detect a simple slip of the tongue that even a seasoned detective might miss. For example, she notices that Dora, who knows that the woman posing as Letty is really her sister Charlotte (Lottie), sometimes mistakenly refers to Letty as Lottie, tipping off the clever Miss Marple.

Craddock has competence and police knowledge, but Miss Marple understands human nature and the power of a lunch or a cup of tea to draw people out.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Miss Jane Marple, a woman, is an amateur sleuth who solves many mysteries, including crimes, as a hobby. Miss Marple is older and retired. She is a close friend of Sir Henry, who is Craddock’s godfather. Miss Marple takes facts into consideration but is especially good at getting people to open up, discerning what people are keeping hidden, and drawing conclusions from their behavior.

Detective-Inspector Dermot Eric Craddock, a man, is a police detective for whom crime solving is a profession. Detective Craddock is younger; his age is not stated but probably under 40. One of the characters describes him as having “manly proportions and [a] handsome face.” He is methodical and attends to the facts. A good listener, he is open minded and does not leap to conclusions.

Miss Marple, who lives in St. Mary Mead, is visiting the town of Chipping Cleghorn. She had been a guest in the hotel where the dead man, Rudi Scherz, had worked. For this reason she and Inspector Craddock end up working together to solve the crime.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team