What does Winston mean by, "Freedom is the freedom to say that two plus two makes four. If that is granted, all else follows" in 1984?

When Winston says that "freedom is the freedom to say that two plus two makes four" in 1984, he is asserting that truth exists independently from the Party's ideology. Crucially, this also asserts that the conditions of truth rest in part upon the external world. If Winston has the freedom to say that "two plus two makes four," he has the freedom to acknowledge existence independent of the Party's say-so.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

When Winston Smith writes this line in his secret diary, he is saying that freedom means having the ability to assert objective truths. The made-up Ingsoc ideology that 2+2=5 represents the way that the Party controls people’s minds. To people like us, 2+2=4 is an objective truth based upon our universally accepted understanding of how math works. If the United States government was to all of the sudden say that 2+2=5, people living in the United States would be able to safely refute this claim with the objective truth. To Winston, this ability is what constitutes freedom. If a person has the ability to state and do what they know is right without fear of suppression or control, they are a truly free person. But people do not have this freedom in Oceania.

The Party has made truths like 2+2=4 obsolete in their effort for total social control. Winston understands that refusing to follow the Party’s logic is the door to true freedom, but his awareness of how the Party uses mechanisms like newspeak and doublethink to limit free thought is dangerous. The Party has such a tight grip on people’s freedoms that even though Winston believes that he is getting away with free thinking, the Party is on to him all along. In the end, after Winston is tortured in the Ministry of Love, he traces 2+2=5 in dust on a table. This is an important moment because it represents that even though Winston understood how the Party maintained control through manipulating truth, the Party was so powerful it ended up controlling his mind too.

Last Updated by eNotes Editorial on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Winston recognizes that the Party will accept nothing less than complete orthodoxy and expects citizens to believe that two plus two equals five. Defying logic in order to subscribe to the Party's view is the ultimate form of control. Winston expresses the importance of independent, rational thought, which is necessary to challenge the Party's authority, by writing in his diary,

Freedom is the freedom to say that two plus two make four. If that is granted, all else follows.

He is saying that autonomous free-thinkers will have the power to undermine the authoritarian regime if they do not conform to the Party's doctrine and think independently.

Deep inside the Ministry of Love, O'Brien tortures and brainwashes Winston until he transforms into an orthodox Party member. At one point, he holds up his hand and demands that Winston state that he has four fingers. As an independent thinker and rational man, Winston cannot exercise doublethink and reject logic. It is only after Winston faces his worst fear that he completely submits to the Party and accepts their skewed version of reality.

Last Updated by eNotes Editorial on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

For Winston Smith, freedom means being able to challenge the Party and its totalitarian control. In Oceania, the Party is all-powerful. It doesn't just rule the country with an iron fist; it tells people what they can do, where they can go, and even what they can think.

To secure absolute control over people's thoughts, the Party constructs its own parallel universe in which, according to the blatantly contradictory slogans put out by the Party, “War is Peace,” “Freedom is Slavery,” and “Ignorance is Strength.”

If anyone is to secure freedom from the Party's control, they need to be able to think for themselves. This means accepting that there's a world of fact where the Party's writ does not run. In this world, two plus two equals four. It always has and it always will, irrespective of what the Party says. But in the totalitarian dystopia of Oceania, if the Party says that two plus two equals five, then everyone is automatically expected to agree.

Winston understands that for people to have freedom, there needs to be a world of fact that is independent of what we or anyone else might think; a realm of truth that cannot be subverted by political or religious dogma. Mathematical equations form part of this world, and the ability to assert their absolute, unwavering truth, irrespective of what the Party might say, is an essential part of what it means to be free.

Last Updated by eNotes Editorial on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In the Ministry of Truth, where Winston Smith works, his job is to manipulate information constantly so that everything that is disseminated unfailingly supports the Party’s view of events—a view that changes by the minute, not just by the day. Truth, in this frame of reference, becomes meaningless: there are no facts, just an endless supply of changes. Winston longs for some solid ground under his feet. Although he knows that mathematical and physical certainties cannot really be altered, his entire occupational responsibility makes him claim the opposite.

Winston is not saying that two and two do not make four. He wants the freedom to be able to oppose the Party’s total control of information. In part, he means that he wishes he could quit his job and not be complicit in supporting the unceasing distortion of information. Winston learns the hard way that there are facts: the main fact is that the Party will never allow anyone the opportunity to challenge its control. The most important word in his statement thus becomes the “if,” because the freedom to state a fact is not available to the people. People do not even have the intellectual freedom to state mathematical truths.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

O’Brien is trying to force the Party’s own logic on Winston; more specifically, he is trying to control and reshape Winston’s reality—what he knows to be true—into whatever will suit the purpose of the Party.  If Winston has the right to insist on his version of the truth—which is a truth that stands independent of ideology—then he can hold on some vestige of being human and determine at least that much of his life for himself. “You believe reality is something objective,” says O’Brien to Winston, but “reality …only in the mind of the Party…Whatever the Party holds to be truth is truth.”  For Winston, if two plus two equals four, then reality is objective, and if this is true he can still seek objective truths and discount the double think of the Party.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
Soaring plane image

We’ll help your grades soar

Start your 48-hour free trial and unlock all the summaries, Q&A, and analyses you need to get better grades now.

  • 30,000+ book summaries
  • 20% study tools discount
  • Ad-free content
  • PDF downloads
  • 300,000+ answers
  • 5-star customer support
Start your 48-Hour Free Trial