Where Civil Blood Makes Civil Hands Unclean

In Romeo and Juliet, what does the line "where civil blood makes civil hands unclean" mean?

Expert Answers
gpane eNotes educator| Certified Educator

This line, from the Prologue, refers to the quarrels between ordinary people and how these can lead to violence and bloodshed. The particular quarrel that this play is concerned with is that between two old noble families of Verona, the Montagues and Capulets.

The key aspect of this line is the word 'civil' which has a double meaning. In the first instance it simply refers to the ordinary people, the citizens of a state (as opposed to the government, army, or legal and religious institutions). However, it can also be taken to denote qualities such as courtesy, respect, restraint, rationality and dignity, which ideally should be present in the people of a supposedly civilized and well-ordered state.

The use of the word 'civil' becomes quite ironic in the Prologue as in the course of the play the Montagues and Capulets will be shown to be anything but courteous and dignified in their dealings with each other. They prosecute an ancient feud which consumes all their energies. There is no rational basis for such enmity, nor does it tend to any worthwhile end. Rather, it causes unnecessary suffering and needless deaths like those of the young lovers, Romeo and Juliet, who would rather indulge positive emotions of love instead of hate. Their tragedy is that they are caught up in this ongoing warfare between their respective families. In the end, their deaths do bring about a reconciliation between the two houses, but there is a sense that it is really too late.

In this Prologue, the Montagues and Capulets are also implicitly condemned for degrading their nobility by their quarrelsome and futile actions. They are of ancient lineage and high rank - 'two households, both alike in dignity' - yet they abjectly fail to set a good example to the rest of society.  

favoritethings eNotes educator| Certified Educator

This line means that citizens of Verona will dirty their hands (in a literal and figurative sense) with the blood of other citizens.  Literally, the old feud between the Montagues and the Capulets will cause new fights to break out, and the blood of each side will be spilled by the other.  We see this in the very first scene, when Sampson and Gregory from the house of Capulet fight (for no real reason other than the feud) with the two servants from the house of Montague.  Figuratively, the old feud will cause members of each family to do things that will render them guilty of wrongdoing.  We see this when Tybalt kills Mercutio and when Romeo then slays Tybalt.  Mercutio is not even a Montague, but he fights Tybalt when he believes Romeo to be behaving dishonorably.  Then Romeo kills Tybalt, his new relative by marriage.  

tyler-k | Student

No Fear Shakespeare translates this line as: "...and citizens stain their hands with the blood of their fellow citizens." This literally means that the townspeople are killing each other. This line sets up the play; it tells the reader that lives will be lost, and there will not be an entirely happy ending.