What does this say about history in general and historical evidence in particular?Colin Thubron said, "Marco Polo produced a travel portrait so rich in details that it once seemed too outlandish to...

What does this say about history in general and historical evidence in particular?

Colin Thubron said, "Marco Polo produced a travel portrait so rich in details that it once seemed too outlandish to be believed, has now been largely corroborated"

Asked on by hannah555

1 Answer | Add Yours

pohnpei397's profile pic

pohnpei397 | College Teacher | (Level 3) Distinguished Educator

Posted on

This quote tells us a few things about history and the nature of historical evidence.

First, it tells us that it is not always easy to know which historical witnesses are telling the truth.  It is clear that not every account written of a journey to some far off land (or account of things that happened in some past time) is true.  Occasionally, however, they are.  It is hard to know which is which unless you are able to actually go to the place involved and examine the evidence.

Second, it tells us that historians are prone to interpreting evidence through the lenses of their own prejudices and beliefs.  Marco Polo's account seemed outlandish compared to what historians once believed to be true.  Because the evidence was contrary to their view of what was likely to be true, they discounted the evidence.

This quote shows some of the difficulties of studying history -- we often have to rely on accounts that may or may not be completely truthful.  In deciding what is true, we are handicapped by our own preconceived notions about what should be true.

We’ve answered 318,966 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question