What does Scout mean in Harper Lee's To Kill a Mockingbird when she speaks of the "starched wall of a pink penitentiary" beginning to close around her?

Expert Answers
Lori Steinbach eNotes educator| Certified Educator

By chapter 14 of To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee, Aunt Alexandra has arrived at the Finches' home, and for Scout more than anyone else this is a disaster. Atticus is glad that she is here, since he is going to be busy with the trial and wants her there for the children; and she is his sister, after all. Calpurnia is not thrilled, but she does not complain and the two women manage to work together. Jem is a few years older than Scout, so he is able to kind of ignore his aunt--and of course he is a boy, so the two of them do not have too many clashes.

For Scout, however, Aunt Alexandria is a major road block and speed bump on the metaphorical road of her life. Everything that Scout is just happens to be everything Aunt Alexandra thinks a young lady should not be. This includes all kinds of things, but one of them is a real point of contention between the two females. Scout is a tomboy and she wears overalls whenever she has a choice. They suit her life as well her temperament, and wearing anything else is an almost monumental sacrifice for Scout. 

Aunt Alexandra, on the other hand, thinks she is doing everyone a favor by trying to change Scout from a tomboy into a model young lady. The easiest thing for her to change is what Scout wears, so that is one of Aunt Alexandria's primary targets. In this chapter, Scout overhears a conversation between her father and Aunt Alexandra about the subject of Scout's distinctively unladylike behaviors, though they never mention Scout's name. While Scout is not certain they are talking about her, we (the readers) are. 

Scout comments that she feels

the starched walls of a pink cotton penitentiary closing in on [her].

What this means, of course, is that she can already feel the restrictions on her freedom to be a tomboy that Aunt Alexandra is about to impose on her. The starch in this comment refers to prim and "girly" clothes which have been pressed (ironed) and starched (made stiff), and of course Scout would see this kind of clothing unappealing both because it does not suit her but also because it is uncomfortable. The "pink cotton" is a specific reference to frilly, girly, distinctly non-tomboyish clothing which, again, Scout abhors. 

The rest of the phrase is a metaphor in which Scout is comparing the potential of having to wear such things to a prison, and she already feels the restrictive walls of Aunt Alexandra's prescribed "proper young lady" wardrobe closing in on her. In short, she feels as if she is a prisoner, about to be smothered (or pressed to death) by the clothes she fears her aunt is about to make her wear. 

Read the study guide:
To Kill a Mockingbird

Access hundreds of thousands of answers with a free trial.

Start Free Trial
Ask a Question