What does Madame Shachter's vision of a fire really represent?

3 Answers | Add Yours

teacherscribe's profile pic

teacherscribe | High School Teacher | (Level 2) Associate Educator

Posted on

It represents the evil of the Nazis and the end of hope for the Jews. 

Beginning with Moishe's account of what happened to all foreign Jews expelled from Sighet - he witnesses Jews digging a trench and then being shot and dumped into it, as well as babies being tossed into the air and shot by Nazi soldiers - many Jews refuse to believe such atrocities could possibly be.  They either hold out hope that the Germans will be defeated or they simply refuse to believe that the Germans will be so evil.

This denial is prominent early in the book.  When the Jews are forced into the ghetto, Wiesel observes, "The ghetto was ruled by neither German nor Jew, it was ruled by delusion" (12).  Later on when they are about to be deported from the ghettos, Wiesel overhears Jews talking about how it is all a ruse for others to rob them while the are sent away on vacation (21).

However, when the Jews are herded into the railroad car and sent out of Hungary, Wiesel notes, "Our eyes opened.  Too late" 23).  Soon after this epiphany, Mrs. Schachter begins having her visions.  Of course, no one wants to believe what she is seeing.  But soon enough the Jews have their eyes opened again by the pit at Auschwitz where the living and dead are being burned.

As they narrowly escape the pit, Wiesel's father asks his son, "'Do you remember Mrs. Schacter, in the train'" (34)?  This is the death of all their hopes and their realization of true evil.

Sources:
clane's profile pic

clane | High School Teacher | (Level 3) Educator

Posted on

Madame Schachter's vision of fire actually represents the crematorium where people are sent, dead or alive, to be burned if they cease to be useful to the Nazi party. Everyone on the train hatedMadame Schachter because she was screaming about her vision of flames which no one could see. When Elie and his father step off the train, leaving Madame Schachter on the train probably to die, they see the thick black smoke and smell the flesh in the air around them and they see, for the first time, that Madame Schachter's vision came true. There were flames engulfing life within the camp. Elie is shocked that this can actually be happening to people in the world and as he is walking the line he contemplates whether or not to kill himself rather than endure the torture to come.

Sources:
kingdomhearts's profile pic

kingdomhearts | Student, Grade 9 | eNotes Newbie

Posted on

well, i surly will need this, um i got a question, what is the name of the ss that was elie's first gard that was nice to him when he was i think in "burkanal"...

We’ve answered 318,994 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question