What does Jan think of Edek in The Silver Sword?

Jan has been traveling with and helping the girls, and he is jealous of Edek at first. Jan and Edek get off to a rough start when Edek is reunited with his sisters, Ruth and Bronia. He doesn't believe Edek's story of escape, and the two boys almost fight. Eventually, though, Jan comes to respect Edek, and they become friends.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In The Silver Sword by Ian Serraillier, Edek is separated from his sisters, Ruth and Bronia, when he is captured by the Germans. A while later, the girls find a ragged boy in the street and bring him to live and travel with him as they seek their brother and try to make their way to Switzerland and look for their parents.

When the three young people get to the transit camp at Posen where Edek is supposed to be, they discover that he has run away that very morning. During mealtime, a brawl breaks out, and Ruth, in the midst of the chaos, reaches out and grabs someone's hand. When she can finally get up, she looks over to see whom she is holding onto and finds her brother, Edek.

Unfortunately, Edek is suffering from tuberculosis, yet he is determined to continue the journey with Ruth, Bronia, and Jan to find their parents. Ruth worries that Jan is not "entirely at ease with Edek." In many ways, Jan has taken over the role that Edek once filled in his sisters' lives. Jan is the protector and the provider as Edek once was, and Ruth worries that there "might be trouble" if Jan resents Edek's presence. Jan has, Ruth realizes, a "jealous nature" and will not want Edek to "usurp" his position.

Indeed, Jan does show some contempt for Edek. He laughs "scornfully" at Edek's story of escape and challenges the truth of it. The boys nearly fight, but Edek stands his ground and sticks to his near-miraculous story. The more Jan listens, however, the more impressed he is by Edek's resourcefulness and courage. The boys come to a truce and begin a lasting friendship.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial Team