What does the incident with Angus Morton's horse tell you about people's general attitude towards deviation in The Chrysalids?  

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In Waknuk society most people pay lip-service to the idea of purity. In reality, however, the rules relating to what is or isn't pure can be bent or ignored if they're difficult to enforce. For it's one thing to devise laws, but quite another thing to enforce them, as the...

See
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

In Waknuk society most people pay lip-service to the idea of purity. In reality, however, the rules relating to what is or isn't pure can be bent or ignored if they're difficult to enforce. For it's one thing to devise laws, but quite another thing to enforce them, as the example of Angus Morton's "mutant" horses shows us.

Even the puritanical government of this dystopian land has to be flexible every now and then, especially when the survival of the community is at stake. We see this in its attitude towards the mutant horses. Just one of these towering brutes can do the work of two ordinary horses. This will have the effect of increasing agricultural productivity and efficiency, which will make it easier for the government to control the population. After all, the happier the people, the more secure and stable the government. So it pays for the powers-that-be to allow for a fair degree of leeway in the law's application and interpretation.

Joseph's none too happy, though. As a fanatical true believer in the values of this society, he doesn't think that such monstrous creatures should be allowed to live. But then, he doesn't need to see the bigger picture; he can afford to adhere rigidly to society's narrow strictures concerning what is or is not pure.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The people do not accept any deviation.  Any unusual things are “Offences” and must be destroyed.  However, they do make exceptions in some cases—such as Angus Morton’s horse.

There are “rumours of great-horses” that no one has seen.  Angus tells everyone that they are certified.

My father was already uneasy in his mind at what he had heard of them, nor was the fact that Angus was the importer of them a commendation; consequently, it may have been with some prejudice that he went to inspect them. (ch 4)

When the inspector does come, there is some trouble with the idea of killing the horse because “the great-horses were costly creatures” (ch 4).  It is interesting that the people are afraid to destroy an abomination that is valuable.

The impending crops were so orthodox that the inspector had posted only a single field, belonging to Angus Morton, for burning. (ch 5)

Since they won’t accept any differences, crops that are not just as expected are burned.  The fact that perfectly good crops and animals are destroyed because they don’t fit someone’s idea of perfect is ridiculous.

Weeks of work gone up in smoke, pigs, sheep and cows gobbling up good food just to produce 'bominations. (ch 9)

Old Angus does get away something though. 

Angus Morton's great-horses still around, an "officially approved" mockery of the Purity Laws… (ch 9)

Apparently Angus has gotten an exception, and he is allowed to keep his horse.  This shows that there is some corruption in the purity standards, and they are at least somewhat aware that the restrictions are silly.

 

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team