In "Lord of the Flies", what does change when Ralph loses his advisor, Piggy?

2 Answers | Add Yours

amy-lepore's profile pic

amy-lepore | High School Teacher | (Level 1) Educator Emeritus

Posted on

Ralph, Piggy, and Simon are all allegorical characters.  They represent something to the meaning of the story beyond themselves, and when they are targeted and killed, one by one, it is essentially as if these human traits are murdered as well, leaving the boys in complete and utter darkness as far a civilization goes.

Ralph represents reason and logic.  He is the original leader, chosen by the boys as a whole.  He is the one who orchestrates the collecting of water, the building of shelters, the collecting of food, and the watching of the signal fire.

Piggy, his friend, represent intelligence and insight.  Piggy is the advisor of Ralph, the one who keeps him on track and helps him prioritize what is important until the rescue. HIs glasses are also a symbol of that insight.  He sees well with them, but is blinded without them.  With them, the boys are able to create fire which is the source of heat and warmth, and gives them the ability to cook food for health. When Piggy is murdered, that insight is gone.  Ralph no longer has that intelligence to lean upon, and the glasses have become the spoils of war just as the meat from the pigs they've hunted seals their victory over the island wildlife.  "Piggy" has become just another member of the hunted wild pigs on the island.

Simon was the first to be killed.  He represented innocence.  The boys' innocence disappears first as they battle the unknown of the island and of life itself with no adult supervision.  The outbreak of war, the beast on the island and the death of Simon, which they all took part in as part of a frenzied attack on something fearful which they perceived as a threat, has forced them to grow beyond the stage of innocence they had before they were shipped off to safety.

Hope this helps!

luannw's profile pic

luannw | High School Teacher | (Level 2) Senior Educator

Posted on

The most profound change when Piggy dies in chapter 11 is that Ralph realizes that civility, reason, and intellect, like Piggy, are dead and that in order to survive, Ralph must now revert to savagery.  Piggy is killed when a rock is pushed off the top of Castle Rock by Roger, onto Piggy.  He is crushed and his body is washed away.  Ralph realizes at once that any hope that Jack and his group will become civil and listen to reason is gone.  Ralph takes off through the brush to hide from the spears being thrown by Jack's tribesmen.  Ralph had held out hope that there was still a chance that the civility that had been in the boys was still there and could be brought back out.  He still had hope that reason would prevail, but Piggy's death wiped out that hope.

We’ve answered 318,917 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question