It was in the clove of seasons, summer was dead but autumn had not yet
been born, that the ibis lit in the bleeding tree.
James Hurst foreshadows the death of Doodle in the first sentence of his story “The Scarlet Ibis.” The ibis dies as well as does Doodle during the time of the year [the clove of seasons] which splits summer from autumn. It was the time that school started.
Hurst frames his story around the changes in the weather. Doodle is sickly during the winter; however, when the spring comes he seems to find the will to attack the hard lessons Brother takes him through. The hurricane season which kills the cotton crop of Brother’s father prefaces the storm which ultimately brings the ibis to the yard.
With skill, the author weaves the elements of the weather into the plot and actions of the characters. Leading to the storm, The boys’ mother, who believes in signs, does not think there will be a storm because she has not heard the “rain frogs.” On the other hand, the father thinks that the sky, the humidity, and the clouds all indicate that a storm is coming. Ignoring all of this, Brother takes Doodle to the swamp to teach him how to row a canoe.
Brother’s pride prevents him from observing his little brother’s health. It was a miracle that Doodle had lived as long as he had. Brother wanted Doodle to be as normal as possible…not for Doodle but for himself. He was proud of Doodle’s accomplishments but also ashamed to have a handicapped brother.
When Brother realizes that Doodle has failed to learn the things that would make him more normal, his spirit becomes bitter; and once again, he feels the mean streak running through his heart. Doodle looks to his brother for some sign of compassion, yet none comes.
Suddenly, the storm erupts like a “Roman candle” advising the reader that this is no ordinary rain. It is a full-fledged thunderstorm which brings with it the danger of being hit by lightning. The symbolism employed in the use of the storm highlights the turmoil within Brother and the last bit of life left in poor Doodle. When Brother leaves Doodle crying for him and trying to keep up with him, the rain is so hard that Brother cannot see actually see Doodle. In fact, metaphorically the rain becomes a wall separating the two brothers from sight and hearing.
Finally, Brother succumbs to guilt and turns to see where Doodle is in the stormy landscape. He returns to look for him, and Brother finds Doodle under a nightshade bush. [Again symbolism at work since the nightshade is often mentioned in reference to death because its berries are poisonous.] Doodle and the Ibis have become one. Both were covered in their own vermilion blood.
I began to weep, and the tear-blurred vision in red before me looked
very familiar. "Doodle!" I screamed above the pounding storm and threw my
body to the earth above his... I lay there
crying, sheltering my fallen scarlet ibis from the heresy of rain.
With his change of heart, Brother tries to cover the body of the innocent Doodle. In his final condemnation of nature’s stormy onslaught on the two brothers, Hurst uses the phrase “the heresy of rain.” Nature does not change for man. It is what it is…snow, sleet, tornado, or whatever. To the author, Brother had to shelter Doodle from the almost sacrilegious attack of the rainstorm.