Fiction Questions and Answers

Start Your Free Trial

What is the difference between a short story and a novel? Thank you!

Expert Answers info

William Delaney eNotes educator | Certified Educator

calendarEducator since 2011

write5,416 answers

starTop subjects are Literature, History, and Social Sciences

To say that a short story is a story which is short is begging the question. Such a definition does not explain what a story is or what is meant by "short." Edgar Allan Poe offered a thorough definition of the short story, and it has pretty much been the accepted definition since his day. Here is Poe's precise definition of the short story.

A skilful literary artist has constructed a tale. If wise, he had not fashioned his thoughts to accommodate his incidents; but having conceived, with deliberate care, a certain unique or single effect to be wrought out, he then invents such incidents--he then combines such events as may best aid him in establishing this preconceived effect. If his very initial sentence tend not to the outbringing of this effect, then he has failed in his first step. In the whole composition there should be no word written, of which the tendency, direct or indirect, is not to the one pre-established design. And by such means, with such care and skill, a picture is at length painted which leaves in the mind of him who contemplates it with a kindred art, a sense of the fullest satisfaction. The idea of the tale has been presented unblemished, because undisturbed; and this is an end unattainable by the novel. Undue brevity is just as exceptionable here as in the poem; but undue length is yet more to be avoided.

Edgar Allan Poe
A review of Hawthorne’s Twice-Told Tales
Graham’s Magazine, May, 1842

 The two most important words in the above quotation are "single effect." A modern short story is intended to produce a single (emotional) effect. This can come at the end of the story or it can be evoked by the overall tone and mood. Poe does not specify what constitutes a "short" story, but the best definition is that it is a story that can be read in a single sitting. (Poe uses "single sitting" when writing about poetry.) If a story (or a poem)  can't be read in a single sitting, it is unlikely to produce a single effect. So what is the definition of the word "story"? A story is a dramatic narrative. A short story is a dramatic narrative that is intended to be read at a single sitting. If it isn't dramatic it is nothing. Sometimes we expect to read a story at a single sitting and the phone rings or the nurse tells us the doctor is ready to see us or we forgot something we left cooking on the stove--but the author intended his story to be read at a single sitting from beginning to end. That is the main difference between a short story and a novel. The novelist does not intend to have his book read at a single sitting. That is why he divides it into chapters. These tell us where we can take a break. Now what is a "sitting"? Some people can sit longer than others. Some people read faster than others--much faster in some cases. (A speed reader could probably read one of Shakespeare's sonnets in three seconds--but I doubt he would get much out of it.) I can only suggest that a sitting should not last much longer than a college lecture, which is typically fifty minutes long because the professor knows that students get restless and start to fidget and tune him out. I further suggest that the length of a short story should be limited by the number of words that can be read aloud with appropriate feeling and emphasis in fifty minutes or one hour. That would equalize speed readers and slow readers. If you can read one hundred words a minute aloud, then a good approximate maximum length for a short story would be around six thousand words. A story like Shirley Jackson's "The Lottery" seems like the ideal length to me--and it certainly produces a single effect!

A short story is a dramatic narrative intended to be read at a single sitting and designed to produce a single effect.

Further Reading:

check Approved by eNotes Editorial

William Delaney eNotes educator | Certified Educator

calendarEducator since 2011

write5,416 answers

starTop subjects are Literature, History, and Social Sciences

Edgar Allan Poe has been called the father of the modern short story. He defined the short story as a short prose narrative designed to produce a "single effect." He used the word "effect" frequently. It means about the same thing as the "feeling" the reader is left with at the end of the story. Poe's own stories often have the effect of horror.

A novel is not confined to producing a single effect. Typically it is broken up into chapters, and these chapters can have their own effects. Because a novel is longer than a short story, the author will usually try to provide variety by shifting scenes and switching from one character's point of view to another's. The author of a novel does not expect his work to be read in a single sitting; therefore he knows he is going to have to keep recapturing the reader's interest, getting his reader re-involved with his characters and their problems.

A lot of people like to read a chapter a night before falling asleep. This means the author might have to expect some of his readers to take several weeks to finish his book.

check Approved by eNotes Editorial

Reuben Lindsey eNotes educator | Certified Educator

calendarEducator since 2005

write1,774 answers

starTop subjects are Literature, History, and Business

Consider also that an author has chosen to the short story format over the novel format. Authors make these decisions for very specific reasons. Edgar Allen Poe, often considered the father of the short story, stated in the Philosophy of Composition that the most powerful expression of emotion must be experienced in one sitting. To interrupt the reading is to take away from the impact of the emotion and or message. With that in mind, the short story author, like the poet, is typically much more concerned with the human emotional experience as opposed to the human social and/or philosophical experience.

In order to accomplish this goal, short story authors will often leave off one part or over-emphasize one part of the plot structure. A typical plot involves exposition, rising action, climax, falling action, and resolution. Some stories, like the classic The Lady or the Tiger will completely ignore resolution in order to empasize exposition, and therefore characters. The story isn't about what happens, its about what the characters experience. Sonny's Blues is another great example of this emphasis on exposition. Other stories will skip exposition all together, giving no background to the characters, which allows the readers to focus on conflict. Hemingway's Hills are like White Elephants is a great example of this.

Therefore, a reader of short stories, as opposed to novels, should consider where the author chooses to focus the little space he has.

mrerick eNotes educator | Certified Educator

calendarEducator since 2007

write446 answers

starTop subjects are Literature and History

While this might seem obvious, the basic answer is length. The link below will explain more detailed, but because a short story is shorter than a novel, there are many things that end up different. The protagonist in a short story often doesn't experience any major change. They are quickly personified in the beginning and often remain static for the duration of the story. In a novel, our characters often experience some great (or small) change in thought, belief, etc. In a short story, all action usually builds to one event. In a novel, there can be multiple plot lines intertwined with multiple conflicts. In a short story, the number of smaller events that lead up to a conflict or toward resolution are often limited. With the extra length in a novel, that "build-up" and "let-down" period can include many, many events.

Hope that helped.

atyourservice | Student

A short  story usually focuses on one story and trying to build that one story and the length is usually shorter than that of a novel. A novel on the other hand could have many conflicts, and events that take place before the end. Novels are also has many different themes.

maria-vivanco | Student

A short story tends to be short and the plot doesn't really require much writing and the characters don'tface any  different changes. The storyline is more basic and unravels quickly and is more centered. However a novel is more complex and the plot unravels in chapters and different things happen and more of those changes occur. 

crystaltu001 | Student

A short story focuses on one event only, and it's about specifically that one event. A novel tells multiple events that lead up to one big one

acompanioninthetardis | Student

A short story is exactly what is sounds like, a short story, (im not going to put a page limit on it). A novel whereas is significantly longer. 

yukyukco | Student

Short story focuses on one event and its direct surroundings like what just had happened in the story and what was the result of that particular event only. It centers in a single happening and once it ends it is also the ending of the story. On the other hand, novel can widen the range or the scope of a story into multiple events. The story can be diverted into many focuses and it can shift away from one event to another. 

In terms of their length, of course, novel is more lengthy than short story.

parama9000 | Student

Short story is basic while a novel will portray more themes, and will have greater complexity, and is always longer.

Yojana_Thapa | Student

Despite its length, Short story is more basic. The protagonist in the short story doesn't really face many changes. While in a novel, the protagonist learns it lesson, starts developing more. In a novel we see everything, what the author is trying to convey to the readers. In a novel, the plot is more clear and more explanatory, while in a short story the plot is basic. A novel has more literary device, for example metaphor, personification, simile. Most importantly, symbolisms. The symbolisms in a novel is big and it connects to the theme. A novel portrays not only one theme but many. A novel and A short story share many similarities but a novel is more complex.

sesh | Student

   Basically, the length is the major difference. In short stories, 'consiseness' is there, but in the contrary, in novels scenes and things are well described. Usually short stories contain one setting and one plot whereas in novels there are multiples. When it comes to the no. of characters, there are a lot of characters involved in a novel, but a short story is confined to a limited number ber of characters.

   So because of the above reasons, novel takes time to finish but short story can be read at once.

kimberly1410 | Student

In many short stories are in one sitting, which means you would read it withoud having to go and have a break, and can often be read quikly. Uually short stories arn't well developed and only have one conflict. They also finish right at the climax. With  one type of view and the fisrt sentence indicates the theme and whats the story is going to be about. Hope this helped

lil-lizard | Student
Often in a short story the characters are everyday people that appear to simply live in the real world. In a short story the author generally ‘cuts to the quick’ of the characters lives and ‘to the quick’ of the pain that the character is in. Minimalist prose creates not only the illusion of a ‘storyless story’ in its commitment to apparently disjointed fragments , but also of an ‘authorless story’ in its extraordinary power to articulate a different voice Writers of the minimalist short story manipulate figurative speech to present what appears to be a single event, a mere incident, a nothing-is-happening-here story that is actually an intricate figurative pattern that reflects or signifies the human condition and capacity. With this technique these writers create a mathematical relationship, a ratio, between the singular and universal, the part and the whole, the trifle and the significant. short fictions begin in the middle and end in the middle. In the syntax of their figurative design they stand synecdochically for a whole experience and metonymically for some universal knowledge. Although the minimalist short story often has an air of bleakness about it, just as often it is laced with humor—cutting, sad, understated, black, but humor nonetheless.
shfaq | Student

in novel they are many chariecer

read novej take more time

tabieric | Student

A short story is a fictional prose narrative shorter and more focussed than a novel ,usually deal with a single charecter.

A novel is a fictional prose narrative of considerable length,usually having  a plot that unfolds by actions,dilogue and thoughts of the varied charecters.

walefilip | Student

Obviously, the lenght, is the difference between a novel and a shortstory. Shortstory,is a form of fictional prose that ranges from 500-2,000 words and 50-100 pages that contain major events of a literary work. On the other hand, Novel is also a form of prose that has a range of 2,000-10,000 words. Unlike shortstory that deals with major events, it deals with the elaborate sense of a literary work containing both major and minor events that could be found in any literary work.