In Cry, the Beloved Country, what are the contrasts and comparisons between Stephen Kumalo and James Jarvis?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Alan Paton's Cry, the Beloved Country provides readers with obvious similarities and differences between the two characters of Stephen Kumalo and James Jarvis.

Both men live in South Africa. By the end of the novel, both men have lost their sons. Also, both men want for nothing more than...

See
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

Alan Paton's Cry, the Beloved Country provides readers with obvious similarities and differences between the two characters of Stephen Kumalo and James Jarvis.

Both men live in South Africa. By the end of the novel, both men have lost their sons. Also, both men want for nothing more than South Africa to become prosperous again.

Yet it is their differences which speak to Paton's desire for brotherhood and camaraderie. Jarvis has lost his son, Arthur, who was murdered. Unfortunately, it was Kumalo's son, Absalom, who murdered Arthur. Also, Jarvis is rich and white. Kumalo is poor and black.

Given that both of their sons left for Johannesburg (another similarity), neither of the fathers know about the lives their sons lead there. Arthur has become an activist, and Absalom has wandered away from his religious upbringing—becoming an adulterer, thief, and murderer.

Toward the end of the novel, Stephen wishes for nothing more than to help his village of Ndotsheni. But his lack of monetary wealth prevents him from doing so. Jarvis, too, wishes for Ndotsheni's prosperity. It is his monetary wealth that helps the village begin to prosper.

One final similarity between the two men is their mourning. Not only do they mourn the deaths of their sons, they also both seem to mourn the death of traditional values and the morality of the past.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The differences between Stephen Kumalo and James Jarvis are most obvious in the novel, but it is their similarities that are thematically most significant and satisfying. These two men of South Africa represent the reality of apartheid as it was practiced. Kumalo is a poor African, living in the barren and impoverished village of Ndotsheni, located symbolically in a valley. Jarvis, in contrast, is a wealthy white man living on a lovely estate, High Place, near Ixopo. High Place is located near Ndotsheni geographically, but exists culturally in another world. Stephen and James live as neighbors who never meet because of the political and cultural divide enforced by apartheid, as well as by centuries of social tradition. Neither man knows or understands the life of the other, until their lives intersect through an act of violence, and they both become grieving fathers.

The similarities between Stephen and James become increasingly evident as they are portrayed as the fathers of lost sons, one a murderer and the other murdered, yet both victims in a larger sense. Stephen and James both love and grieve for their sons. Neither understands the senselessness of Arthur Jarvis's death. Each had lost touch with his son and was unaware of the life he had been leading at the time of the crime. Both men, gentle and compassionate, feel their wives' suffering. 

The most profound similarity between Stephen and James is that in their grief, they choose love over hatred. When Stephen approaches James to express his shame and sorrow over Arthur's death, James does not turn him away. Out of this meeting, a bond is formed, one man feeling deep compassion for the other. James comes down from High Place, literally, to embrace the people of Ndotsheni and continue his son's social work. Arthur's young son seeks to learn the Zulu language from the elder Stephen. The lives of Stephen and James are far more similar than different in terms of each man's humanity, and through their relationship, Patton's novel holds out hope for the future of South Africa.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team