What conflict does the old woman cause for the sniper?

Expert Answers
teachsuccess eNotes educator| Certified Educator

After the Irish War of Independence, the Anglo-Irish treaty gave 26 of the 32 Irish counties the right to form a free state. The 6 northern counties seceded from the Free State. The British also maintained ports along the Irish coast in Cobh, Bearhaven and Lough Swilly. Some of the IRA (Irish Republican Army) independence fighters were not at all happy with the provisions of the treaty. The Irish Civil War was a result of this dissatisfaction; disgruntled IRA soldiers fought Free-Staters for pre-eminence in further negotiations with the British.

In the story, the sniper first spies the old woman when she speaks to the machine gunner in the armored car. It turns out that she is an informer; as she points in his direction, the sniper realizes that she is giving his position away. He shoots the gunner and then the old woman. The old woman sets up a conflict for the sniper because she is Irish as well; in the Irish Civil War, Irishmen fought each other, informed on each other, and suffered the miseries of prolonged warfare as a people. The miserable conditions of war brought death and poverty on the people. The author describes the old woman's tattered shawl, a symbol of her poverty.

Because of the civil war, the sniper has no choice but to shoot an old woman he would otherwise have treated as his own grandmother in better days. This conflict between loyalty and self-preservation presented many agonizing choices for those who fought.

teachsuccess eNotes educator| Certified Educator

Another conflict the old woman causes for the sniper: either he shoots to kill both the machine gunner in the armored car and the old woman or risk everyone on the enemy side knowing whose side he is on. However, the sniper incurs a risk when he does shoot; his position is given away immediately.

Although he is shot as a result of his decision, the sniper eventually comes up with a plan to escape. Sadly, he finds out too late that his subterfuge has caused him to shoot his own brother. Whether the enemy sniper he has killed is actually his own brother, O'Flaherty does not say. However, both IRA snipers and Free-Staters once fought in the same Irish Army before the Irish Civil War: they were all brother soldiers at one time. The war has splintered old alliances and old loyalties.