History (General)

Start Free Trial

What are the negative and positive effects of war?

Negative effects of war can include loss of life, destruction of cities and the environment, and human suffering. Positive effects of war can include the defeat of problematic governments, the correction of injustices, advances in technology and medicine, and a reduction of unemployment.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

As other Educators have already noted, the negative effects of war include the loss of millions upon millions of lives. In World War Two, around 60 million people were killed. Conversely, a positive effect of war is its potential to save lives. If World War Two had not have happened—if the United States, the United Kingdom, and other countries had not declared war against Nazi Germany—it’s likely Adolf Hitler’s regime would have systematically killed millions upon millions of more people.

As you mull over the positive and negative effects of war, you might want to rethink the use of “positive” and “negative.”

War is a terrible, ghastly, deadly enterprise. For people involved in wars, it’s much more than a “negative”: it’s constant terror, suffering, and possible death. You might want to check out some nonfiction accounts of war, like Evan Wright’s Generation Kill, to get a clearer understanding of war’s brutality.

Furthermore, the upside or “positive effects" of certain wars seem to be debatable. Many people believe America’s Civil War was a positive war. It ostensibly led to the prohibition of slavery. Yet some notable figures, like historian Howard Zinn and legal scholar Michelle Alexander, see the aftermath of the Civil War as a way for America to implement a different sort of slavery, which isn’t a “positive.”

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Contrary to the common belief that war has only negative effects, it also has some positive impacts. However, whereas the negative effects of war are the same regardless of the place of war, the positive effects may vary depending on where the war occurred. The most common negative impacts of war include loss of human lives, economic losses due to destruction of capital as well as disruption of trade, human suffering, the spread of diseases, displacement of people and destruction of the environment, among others.

On the other hand, war can also impact the economy positively in the short term as during the Great Depression during the 1930s in the United States. The war mobilization efforts and military spending stirred capacity utilization and reduced unemployment through increased army conscription. Technological advancements are also a positive impact of war. The railroad networks of the Europeans for instance, that had a significant military strategic input in terms of countering enemy attacks, also helped the civilians. The GPS system which was specifically developed to enhance navigation by U.S military during the 1990’s has found great use among the civilians to date. The First World War helped establish machinery that would help maintain world peace. The League of Nations was founded after WWI as a platform to settle disputes peacefully and even though it has been criticized for failing to avoid World War II, it set precedence for the formation of the United Nations. Some wars have also led to the end of despotic leadership in various countries across the world such as the Libyan civil war that led to the ousting of Muammar Gaddafi in 2011.

In conclusion, even though war has negative effects, it also has some notable positive impacts.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The question of positive and negative effects of war is primarily dependent upon the nature of a particular war, but one can argue with certainty that all wars have disastrous effects on both the combatants and civilians, and a few wars have some positive outcomes.  The issue might be better phrased as, "Is a particular war justified by its potential benefits?"

In World War II, for example, the world was facing an ideology in Europe--National Socialism ("Nazis")--that destroyed and would go on to destroy, if successful, an uncountable number of people based on racial, religious, and medical characteristics.  The approximately 8 million Jews who were killed by the Nazis would have been only a minor number had the Nazi regime succeeded in its goal of controlling western and eastern Europe.  To stop this movement, those who opposed the Nazi ideology went to war, but in the process of defeating the Nazis (and the Japanese), a staggering number of civilians were killed, wounded and displaced.  In addition, the number of killed and wounded combatants, on all sides, is staggering.  Although one can argue this war had to be fought, the human cost is actually unknowable.

All wars have benefits, the principal two being technological advances and advances in medical science.  War accelerates both technological and medical advances because all sides are attempting to invent better ways of killing and better methods of preserving the lives of combatants, and some of these advances benefit the civilian populations, assuming they survive the war.

It is reasonable to conclude that all wars are bad, but, in rare cases, war is forced upon the participants by the actions of one or all parties.  It is also reasonable to believe that the negative effects of war, in all cases, far exceed the potential benefits.  The fact is, there are no good wars.  There are only wars that are less bad than others.  If you interviewed a thousand combatants in various wars, you would find it difficult to find any who would want to go through combat a second time.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The negative effects of war are, of course, death and destruction.  Millions can die in big wars like WWII.  Cities can be devastated, hurting a country’s economy.  These things cause terrible human misery.

There are, however, also possible positive effects of war.  War can correct terrible injustices.  For example, the US Civil War caused an end to slavery in that country.  World War II ended the Holocaust.  Wars can also lead to technological advances that help society.  One instance of this is the development of air travel after WWII, which was strongly influenced by the wartime development of large, long-range bombers.   

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial Team