What is most appealing about "Our Casuarina Tree?"

Expert Answers
Ashley Kannan eNotes educator| Certified Educator

I find myself persuaded by the element of nostalgia for the past that is featured in the love of the tree in the poem.  As I get older, I find myself searching and seeking out those objects that tell a narrative that is relegated to the domains of what was.  In the horrific conditions of what is and the uncertainty of what can be, I think that discovery of these objects, fossils that show a pattern of existence and evidence of life, become extremely important to finding happiness in being.  This is where I think that the poem is most appealing.  The tree carries with it the remembrances of a past time that can no longer be replicated.  It is precisely for this reason that the speaker, presumably Dutt, has nothing but love for the tree.  The tree represents a portal, a door through which some connection with a time that is vastly different from what is and what can be is experienced.  This love of something that has a transformative effect in the subjective of the individual, but nothing in the external is what I find devastatingly beautiful about the vision of the tree in the poem.  It is one in which there is a pain about the past, but only because the past was something of pure joy and bliss.  The tree is seen as a "carousel" of sorts, something that we enter and are transported within its movements to a point in time where we know what it means to love and what it feels like to be loved.  As the speaker has become older, she understands how painful being in the world is without such an element, which is why she has such an attachment to the tree.  As I get older, I find myself understand more and more what attachment is there and seek to find my own as she has found hers.  In this, I think that the most appealing aspect of the poem is evident.