Villanelles are sometimes criticized as elaborate exercises in trivial wordplay. How would you defend Thomas's poem against this charge?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

I think that one of the absolute last words that anyone would use to describe this poem is trivial . Thomas has described what seems to be a universal phenomenon: a person's belief, when they are on their deathbed, that they have not done enough or that they have not...

Unlock
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Start your 48-Hour Free Trial

I think that one of the absolute last words that anyone would use to describe this poem is trivial. Thomas has described what seems to be a universal phenomenon: a person's belief, when they are on their deathbed, that they have not done enough or that they have not lived as they should. In the end, the poet (or, at least, the speaker of the poem) asks his own father to refuse to die; he wants his father to fight against death and remain alive. It is heartbreaking, this movement from the universal to the personal, the general to the specific. This subject matter, and its treatment in the poem, is the opposite of trivial; it is more accurate to describe it as essential or fundamental to the human experience. And rather than losing meaning with each repetition of the first and third lines of the poem, these lines seem to gather meaning and grow as they are repeated in each successive stanza.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Poems in any form can be written well or badly. Many of the very complex forms such as the villanelle which rely on complex combinations of meter and rhyme are very difficult to write well; unskilled poets attempting them often struggle so much with the mechanics that they end up writing really horrible poems, choosing words just to fit the metrical scheme rather than for poetic effect. Just because it's a difficult form for an unskilled writer, though, does not mean that it is inherently a bad or trivial form in the hands of a skilled poet like Thomas. 

Thomas' poetry in general relies heavily on a Welsh tradition of hypnotic use of melody. None of the syntax in the poetry is wrenched awkwardly to fit the meter, and the almost litany-like quality of the repetitions contributes to the solemnity of the subject. The refrains are used well, with the grand and magnificent tone of the first five stanzas leading to a dramatic twist in the pleading tone of the final stanza, in which we discover that the poet is actually addressing his father. The formality of the form prevents the subject from becoming mawkish, and the form is handled with great skill.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team