How did colonial laws in "The Birth of a White Nation" by Jacqueline Battalor legalize sexual violence against black women?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

According to Battalora in The Birth of a White Nation, colonial legislatures, specifically those in the Chesapeake, legalized sexual violence against Black women in several ways. One was that they disallowed any Black person from testifying against whites in court. This denied enslaved people and free people of African descent the ability to testify against their attackers. Black people were also forbidden to defend themselves (or, indeed, their female family members) physically from attack, as they could not own nor use any kind of weapon according to law. Laws also basically indemnified whites from sexual assault by stipulating that the status, slave or free, of the child was determined by the status of its mother. So white men could have sexual relations with enslaved women with the only consequences being the birth of an enslaved child. These "miscegenation laws" together represented a major departure from English law. These miscegenation laws, on the other hand, harshly punished enslaved men for sexual relations with whites, a development that began after 1662. Prior to that, Battalora writes, people of European and African ancestry were "treated similarly for sexual violations."

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Write a paragraph about how colonial laws legalized sexual violence against black women, how black women took roles of white women sexually, and how the increased reproduction in black women advanced property value of a plantation.

Technically, colonial laws did not legalize sexual assault on black or, to be more precise, enslaved black women. Like other violent offenses, sexual assault and rape was illegal regardless of the victim. But historians find very few cases in which men were prosecuted for rape, whether of white or black women. This does not mean that the crime did not occur, but simply that there were reasons why it was not prosecuted. Women did not feel comfortable reporting the crime, and the male-controlled courts did not think it important enough to pursue prosecution. Given the unequal social status of African American women, it is likely that sexual assault was rampant in colonial America.

Colonial law encouraged sexual assault of enslaved women in another way. During the seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries, colonies in the Caribbean and every colony with a large enslaved population passed laws that made slavery hereditary. Along with these laws, they passed legislation that determined the status of an enslaved person based on their mother's status. So, in short, a child born to an enslaved woman would be enslaved, and a child born to a free woman would be free. This meant that slave owners and their sons could engage in sexual activity with enslaved women without worrying about the condition of any children that would result from sexual activity. (Having a child out of wedlock with a white woman usually resulted in a fine, and the father among others had to post a bond for the care of the child.) So in this sense, the radicalized, hereditary nature of slavery as it developed in the colonies basically indemnified white men for the sexual assault of enslaved women. It is very difficult to measure empirically, but written sources suggest that sexual activity between whites and the enslaved was rampant, and given the inequalities in power relations, it is impossible to categorize these interactions as anything other than sexual assault. While there is no evidence that whites engaged in sexual assault with enslaved women to produce slaves for sale, it is well-known by historians of slavery that children of mixed ancestry were sold as enslaved prostitutes in some cities, and tended to be valued as house servants on large plantations throughout the South. More generally, as the cotton economy expanded in the early nineteenth century, and the demand for slaves increased, slave owners had a financial interest in their slaves' natural increase.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Updated on