In Twilight Billy Black was in a wheel chair and could not get out, because he is paralyzed, but in New Moon he is walking and driving a car. How is that possible?
Expert Answers
| Certified Educator
calendarEducator since 2012
write2,471 answers
starTop subjects are Literature, History, and Social Sciences
No, Billy Black is consistently portrayed as being confined in his wheel chair. Whenever he does need to go somewhere, Jacob has to drive him. You may be getting him confused with one of the other characters on the reservation, like Harry Clearwater, Seth and Leah's dad. One of the elders of the Quileute tribe like Billy, Harry Clearwater is also a good friend to Bella's father, Charlie Swan; both men enjoy fishing together. Harry has a heart attack in New Moon, and the news of his death serves as the catalyst for Edward's decision to go to the Volturi.
Related Questions
No Billy does not walk in the New Moon Jacob usually drives Billy around or in that book some from the pack. In Twilight when Bella first met them I think Charlie made a reference to Jacob being too young to drive but Billy responded that he had to get around so way.
Ask a Question
Popular Questions
- In "New Moon" does Bella really hear Edward or just imagine it?Answer the question, but please,...
-
1 educator answer
- Why won't Edward change Bella in New Moon? He wanted to in number one, why not now? Nothing's...
-
2 educator answers
- What did Carlisle and Esme give Bella for her birthday?
-
1 educator answer
- In New Moon, what does it mean when Jacob says, "It's a wolf thing" while Bella counters with,...
-
1 educator answer
- In the New Moon film there are a number of instances where the word "Mono" is used can explain...
-
1 educator answer
- Is Bella happy with Edward's return?
-
1 educator answer
- Why won’t Edward let Bella hug Jacob in the very last chapter in New Moon?
-
1 educator answer
- New Moon movie adaptationHow did you feel about the New Moon movie as compared to the book? Did...
-
4 educator answers
Student Answers