Studying partition literature has opened our horizons and allowed us to view it from various perspectives. In the novel Basti, memories played a central role, as the narrator is expressing his views and reliving the past. In the novel Ice-Candy Man by Sidhwa, the trauma suffered by women was portrayed, which is differently presented by Lalithambika in her short story "A Leaf in a Storm." Manto's "Toba Tek Singh" took us into the asylum, where lunatics were more sane than the wise outside, whereas Amitav Ghosh, in his Shadow Lines, gave an insight into Bengal Partition and trauma suffered by the family. All these histories and incidents documented by the writers are based on one incident (i.e., partition), but still, the perspectives, approaches, and narration are different from one other. Critically analyse the common themes in the texts and highlight the importance and relevance of studying and reading these issues based on your understanding. (You can refer to as many texts as you want of your choice, the ones I have mentioned are just for the reference). I have mentioned the themes above which can be taken as common.

In examining these examples of partition literature, the ways that themes of memory, trauma, women, and family are expressed can be compared in Bapsi Sidhwa’s Ice Candy Man and Amitav Ghosh’s Shadow Lines. Sidhwa’s novel, alternatively titled Cracking India, focuses on women, showing how class affects their experiences of violence and trauma. Ghosh emphasizes generational differences and reveals the lasting effects of separation from the homeland.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Prominent themes that emerge in partition literature include memory, especially in relationship to processing or repressing trauma, the diverse roles of women, and the effects on family. Two works in which several of themes emerge are Ice Candy Man, which is also titled Cracking India , by Bapsi Sidhwa...

See
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

Prominent themes that emerge in partition literature include memory, especially in relationship to processing or repressing trauma, the diverse roles of women, and the effects on family. Two works in which several of themes emerge are Ice Candy Man, which is also titled Cracking India, by Bapsi Sidhwa and The Shadow Lines by Amitav Ghosh. In their intimate portraits of characters whose lives are turned upside down by partition, both novels feature young people who will shape post-independence society. Sidhwa’s novel focuses on female experiences as they are affected by class as well as their interactions with men. Ghosh includes an array of male and female characters, suggesting how contrasting experiences relate to those in different generations as well as those who struggle to identify with a South Asian homeland.

Sidhwa presents class as a protective cover that is stripped away through the events of partition. The colonial system had helped to buttress inequalities which shielded girls like Lenny from the harsh realities that her Hindu nanny, Ayah, faced. The rapid, traumatic changes that the girl and her family endure alter her memory of childhood; Lenny learns that her elite home cannot protect her from violence and that her assumption of safety was an illusion.

Ghosh offers a broader framework for viewing partition by setting part of the novel in England. The physical distance from India can be compared to the emotional distance from the homeland as it shifts from subjugated colony to two independent nations. The trauma of Partition, which leads to Tridib’s death, affects the survivors in contrasting ways. The grandmother, Thamma, loses faith in both past and future, while the younger relatives must work past personal loss to shoulder the burden of nation-building.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team