What Is The Central Conflict In The Story "two Kinds" By Amy Tan?

In the story "Two Kinds," what does the main character desire, and what blocks her from achieving it?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The main character, Jing-mei, desires to please her parents and make them proud. However, the only hindrance is that whereas she wants her mother to accept her as she is, an average child without exceptional talents, her mother will only be happy if she becomes outstanding at something. Therefore, the mother goes to a great extent to mold Jing-mei into a child prodigy by engaging her in an endless search for talent including a stint at being a Chinese Shirley Temple, balancing on her head without support and playing the piano. But as each attempt yielded dismal results and disappointment, so did Jing-mei become resentful of her mother’s efforts at turning her into someone she was not. She simply wanted to be accepted for who she was. Her resentment pushed her to sabotage her piano career debut and embarrass her parents in front of their friends. In the years that followed before the death of her mother, Jing-mei continued to disappoint her mother by pursuing her own ends and being herself. Even though Jing-mei desired to please her mother, her lack of ambition for exceptionality and resignation to an ordinary life stood in the way.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The main conflict in “Two Kinds” is between mother and daughter (character vs. character).  Jing-mei is not a child prodigy, and her mother wants her to be.  Jing-mei, the main character, wants to please her mother but she wants to be herself too.

Jing-mei’s mother wants more than anything to be able to praise her daughter to her friends.  She wants Jing-mei to be some kind of prodigy, just as Waverly is a chess champion.

Unfortunately, Jing-mei does not have the talent or dedication to become a prodigy.  The dream is not really Jing-mei’s.  She wants to make her mother happy, but she also wants to be herself.  She wants her mother to appreciate and love her for who she is.  Ultimately, her lack of distinct accomplishment helps maintain the rift between mother and daughter.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What does the main character desire, and what blocks her from achieving it?

"Two Kinds" is a short story that appears in Amy Tan's novel The Joy Luck Club. In this story, Jing-mei Woo reflects on her childhood—specifically her mother's expectations of her. Since Suyuan grew up in China and had traumatic experiences that led her to move to California, and Jing-mei has the advantages and opportunities of an American childhood, much is expected of the daughter. Jing-mei believes her mother wants her to be some type of "prodigy," and Suyuan attempts to model her daughter after Shirley Temple. Jing-mei admits that she is initially excited for her promising future, her fame and success. However, once she figures out she does not have the talents her mother so desperately wants her to have, Jing-mei begins to rebel.

Much of the story centers on Jing-mei's attempt to become a skilled pianist after her mother sees a young Chinese girl playing piano on a television show. Jing-mei goes to lessons, but she says she is "determined not to try." At...

This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

this point, she simply wants to go against her mother's wishes. Even after she gives a terrible recital performance, Jing-mei is expected to practice piano. This leads to an outburst where she tells her mother she wishes she'd never been born. Her heartless statement hits home with Suyuan, who had to abandon twin babies in China when fleeing her village (she presumes they are now dead). Ultimately, what Jing-mei seems to want is for her mother to accept her for who she is, not hope or expect her to make up for the loss of her other two children. Jing-mei feels an immense amount of pressure, which makes her want to act out and to resist.

Last Updated by eNotes Editorial on