Does society dictate government? Does society dictate the government? Vice versa?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles
Society does dictate government, but government perpetuates society. When a government is first established, it reflects the society that exists then, or that the founders want to exist. At the same time, the government then puts in place laws and social conventions that continue the type of society.
Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Society dictates government in many instances. The Arab Spring is a most recent example of this occurring, especially with the change in government in Egypt recently. All of this came about because of the people voicing, as well as demonstrating, their opposition to Hosni Mubarak and his policies. Therefore society directly influenced Egyptian government.

Of course, as mentioned in the above posts, government does dictate the actions, or lack thereof, in a society. Governments have the capability and authority to enact laws and policies that have a direct influence on what people, businesses, groups, and organizations can do within a particular government's jurisdiction. This government power subsequently impacts what courses of action individuals, companies, and others take, whether for the betterment of society or not.

A company may decide to invest heavily in alternative energy because of government financial incentives. This directly affects the society in which the company operates. It could promote better air quality, more jobs, and more economic growth - - all beneficial to that specific society within that government jurisdiction.

Government

 

Arab Spring

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Interesting question.

Look at how America became a unique independent country in the late 1700's.  After being colonized by European countries, we carved out towns and farms in the colonies and pushed westward. We were in a situation unlike the countries whose citizens immigrated to America. It required a lot of individual toughness and responsibility. This was reflected in how we set up our governent once we became an independent country. In this case, society dictated government.

Later, when we became a settled and wealthy country, we added a lot of social programs that caused some changes in our society (some good, some not so good). In this case, government dictated society.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Ideally, society does dictate government. In America, we elect people into office, therefore, we are choosing who makes up our government. These people either decide on policies, or allow us to vote on certain policies. 

There are some things in government, however, that society does not have control over, and in this respect I would say that government dictates society. The government decides where money goes, what laws need to be upheld and/or amended, etc. I would say, then, that it goes both ways. This allows us to keep our government balanced but also allows the government to keep society in check.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

This is really a chicken and egg kind of question.  To some extent, at least, government dictates society.  For example, Chinese were known as entrepreneurs around Southeast Asia for a long time.  Then their government changed and they became communists who did not engage in entrepreneurial activities.  Now their government has changed again and they are becoming more entrepreneurial.  This suggests that government can dictate society to some degree.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team