Should students be required to speak English in school at all times?  

Expert Answers info

jdoarsinkfield eNotes educator | Certified Educator

calendarEducator since 2009

write10 answers

starTop subjects are Science, Literature, and History

There is no way to police such a policy so that policy cannot be enforced.  In the bathrooms, in crowded hallways, on the playground, lunchroom, etc.  However, the intention of such a policy is to force English Language Learners to become fluent in English  - not just in class but when you order food, when you make plans to go out, when you try to use public transportation, when you need to get a haircut.  Having attended Art School in Italy, the program first put us through a language immersion program for four weeks in Siena where most people did NOT speak english.  So, we had to learn not just verbs and nouns and greetings but we had to learn to live with the language and become fluent.

But, early english language learners, do need to be able to communicate at some point in their native language with others who speak their language in order to "get themselves going".  I was in a program with other Americans and we certainly did not speak english back at the dorm but we were all forced to talk in class and then when we were free the remainder of every day.

I do know, however, at least one person on the program who abjectly refused to learn to speak the language.  She just wanted the art program, made no Italian friends and went back home knowing very little language.  I thought that was crass, self-centered and xenophobic of her.  Additionally, becoming fluent in english for english language learners will be the difference between being working/lower class and their ability to reach higher levels of occupational and educational attainment.

check Approved by eNotes Editorial

Ashley Kannan eNotes educator | Certified Educator

calendarEducator since 2009

write16,848 answers

starTop subjects are Literature, History, and Social Sciences

The concept of "all times" is probably the part of the question where I find the level of disagreement.  For students learning English as their second language, it is nearly impossible for this process to transpire without some level of reliance on their original language.  It gives them another pattern of recognition in the world, or another way to express their experience in the world.  For them to abandon it in place of English reminds me of those awful moments in assimilationist history, when those who possessed knowledge of another language felt that they had to abandon their own heritage in order to adopt an "American" one.  In the final analysis, it should be something that students are able to learn English as a second language while possessing the lively vitality of another one.  This makes it a challenge for educators who have to teach English as a Second Language, but being able to utilize a student's background, as with any teaching, will allow for greater benefits than shutting this background off from the educational aim.

check Approved by eNotes Editorial

msteacher203 eNotes educator | Certified Educator

calendarEducator since 2009

write6 answers

starTop subject is Literature

I agree with many of the answers already set forth. I want to add that I teach my students the concept of code-switching. In addition to teaching high school English, I try to mature the whole being of a child by teaching socially acceptable ways to act. The concept of code-switching involves knowing how to act in various situations. You may speak slang at the lunch...

(The entire section contains 7 answers and 1,284 words.)

Unlock This Answer Now


check Approved by eNotes Editorial

Dayna Watsica eNotes educator | Certified Educator

calendarEducator since 2009

write4,795 answers

starTop subjects are Literature, History, and Social Sciences

check Approved by eNotes Editorial

coachingcorner eNotes educator | Certified Educator

calendarEducator since 2008

write1,346 answers

starTop subjects are Literature, Social Sciences, and History

check Approved by eNotes Editorial

bullgatortail eNotes educator | Certified Educator

calendarEducator since 2009

write7,077 answers

starTop subjects are Literature, History, and Social Sciences

check Approved by eNotes Editorial

pohnpei397 eNotes educator | Certified Educator

calendarEducator since 2009

write35,413 answers

starTop subjects are History, Literature, and Social Sciences

check Approved by eNotes Editorial


udonbutterfly | Student

I believe schools should definitely have options. I understand that English may be more useful but if a kid is not motivated to learn a language then it is practically useless. Like myself my former school only offered Spanish but with some petition Chinese and French were added and more kids were beginning to fill each classes. It's great to have options!

check Approved by eNotes Editorial
krishna-agrawala | Student

When the medium of teaching in a school is English, and the native language of the student is other than English, then it is in the interest of student to become proficient in speaking in English. And the best way to gain proficiency in a language is to practice speaking it.

If a school insists that the students speak English in school to gain proficiency in the language, there is definitely a lot of  merit in this approach. Particularly, a school will do well to insist that students speak only in English in the classroom where a subject is taught in English. It will be in the interest of students to encourage them to speak English at other times also. This of course does not mean that the school bans speaking of any other language in school premises at other times also. Also there will be occasion when speaking of other language is desirable, for example, to facilitate learning of other languages taught in the school.

check Approved by eNotes Editorial
mkcapen1 | Student
As a school teacher who has worked in an area with a large Hispanic population I am able to see the children struggling to use English. I have seen the same problems for Children who speak Chinese and Arabic in their home. When the children are enrolling in an American school their parents desire that their children receive the best education possible. Many times the parents can not speak English and count on the children to help them to learn it as well. For a student with limited English it is often as struggle to communicate wants and needs. It is easy to take this for granted when one speaks the native language. However, for a frightened child who relates better to the other children who share the same language, being able to communicate with friends in the familiar language can be comforting and helpful. I hate the opportunity to take a science class at a German University when I was in my 30’s. I was fairly fluent in German, but the class was very hard for me. Scientific terms were difficult to translate and created a difficult situation. While my professor taught in German, he took the time to help me understand things in English. The trust established between my professor and peers, who helped me to better, understand their language and allowed me to use mine, were priceless. I always encourage my students to speak to one another in English, but at the same time I have them share words that English speaking people are unfamiliar with speaking. Knowledge of different languages has become very important in our global world. Knowing one another's language can be helpful for all students. I do not believe that children should be expected to speak only English in school at all times. There are times when they will need their native language until they become more fluent in English.
check Approved by eNotes Editorial