Illustration of a marlin in the water

The Old Man and the Sea

by Ernest Hemingway
Start Free Trial

Is Santiago a winner or a loser?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The answer to this question is subjective. It is left up to individual readers to decide if Santiago is a winner or loser, and you then have to defend that stance. If a reader determines winning and losing only by the amount of physical items obtained, then Santiago is a...

See
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

The answer to this question is subjective. It is left up to individual readers to decide if Santiago is a winner or loser, and you then have to defend that stance. If a reader determines winning and losing only by the amount of physical items obtained, then Santiago is a loser and has been a loser for quite some time. He is a fisherman, and he has been very unlucky lately. In this story, he lands the catch of a lifetime. However, he is unable to bring it back with him. He has absolutely nothing to show for all of his heroic efforts. He cannot feed himself with a story, and no one is going to pay him for a catch that exists in story format only. He battled the fish and the sea, and Santiago lost; therefore, he is a loser. On the other hand, the book does end on a slightly positive note. He dreams of the lions, and these dreams show that Santiago's internal drive and spirit to persevere have not been beaten. He still has life in him, and he still plans to do battle. This is the attitude of a winner in many people's opinion.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

At first glance, Santiago in Ernest Hemingway's The Old Man and the Sea appears to be a loser. After all, at the beginning of the story he has not caught a fish for a great deal of time, and by the end of the story he has lost the monster marlin to sharks. By any conventional standards, Santiago would seem to be a failure. However, the story is a little more complicated than such standards allow. While Santiago loses his catch and returns home with nothing but a marlin's skeleton, he still manages to valiantly fight to bring the fish home. Indeed, the epic fight to catch and keep the marlin turns into an inspiring story of struggle, hardship, and the steely resolve not to buckle under pressure. As such, though Santiago loses his marlin, his heroic struggle becomes an inspiring feat of strength and courage. In that case, I would call him a winner, rather than a loser. 

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team