i  really need help ...how do i defend tybalt and lady capulet if they are on trial , they are blamed for the deaths of romeo and julliet ...thanks :)The term patriarchal society must be used xD

5 Answers | Add Yours

amy-lepore's profile pic

amy-lepore | High School Teacher | (Level 1) Educator Emeritus

Posted on

How are you going to put Tybalt on trial?  He's in the tomb.  Hum...

Anyway, both of these characters contribute to the age-old feud for which no one remembers the cause.  Of course, Juliet lives in a patriarchal (male run society as opposed to matriarchal--female run) society.  The men rule the roost. Women obey their fathers and brothers (and other male relatives) until such time they are married, then they obey their husbands, etc. 

Tybalt, then, can bear the brunt of the blame since he is more hot-headed and passionate for the feud than most other characters.  He was ready to take Romeo down at the masquerade, and then after him from scene to scene up to his death.  He also kills Mercutio, who is Romeo's true friend.  Romeo responds (as anyone who is egged on to fight will) by challenging Tybalt despite the Prince's edict.  Tybalt just kept picking at the scab...he never let the sore heal properly.  This is a good point to bring up in your trial.

Good Luck!

 

auntlori's profile pic

Lori Steinbach | High School Teacher | (Level 3) Distinguished Educator

Posted on

A case can be made that the only people who caused Romeo and Juliet's deaths are the two of them. Another case can be made that the Nurse and Friar are to blame for the young lovers' deaths. In fact, there is a more direct connection between the two counselors (one who helped Juliet marry a sworn enemy without telling her mother and one who not only conducted the marriage but also contrived to allow Juliet to escape her parents, allowing them to think she was dead). It might make an interesting argument that Tybalt and Lady Capulet may have had a hand in the deaths but that others were more to blame. In the end, it is the patriarchal feud which is to blame, and that means the two Lords are on the same list as Friar and the Nurse. All four of those names are higher on the blame list than Tybalt and Lady Capulet.

wannam's profile pic

wannam | High School Teacher | (Level 3) Educator

Posted on

If you're coming at the from the angle of a patriarchal society, Lady Capulet is the easiest to defend. She did her duty as a mother in raising Juliet (or you could say in selecting the nurse who raised Juliet). She really had little to do with Juliet's decisions. She was simply the messanger for her husband's edicts. While she did turn her back on Juliet when Juliet refused to marry Paris, this was her duty as a wife. Tybalt's actions can also be blamed on Lord Capulet. If he had allowed Tybalt to go after Romeo during the party, the whole incident might have been avoided. Tybalt would not have lost the fight with Romeo when he was surrounded by Capulets. Juliet would never have met Romeo and therefore never have commited sucide to be with him. If Lord Capulet had simply allowed Tybalt to fight Romeo when he wanted to, the play would have been very different. But, Lord Capulet was the leader of the family and his word had to be obeyed. He scolded Tybalt and pushed Lady Capulet into doing what he wanted. Thus, the fault lies with him and not with the characters subordinate to him.
litteacher8's profile pic

litteacher8 | High School Teacher | (Level 3) Distinguished Educator

Posted on

Since it is a patriarchal society, women are owned by men and expected to obey them. So Juliet would have to obey Tybalt and her father. Lady Capulet's role is a little more complicated. She has to obey her husband. She can't make decisions for Juliet herself, she has to go along with her husband's wishes. So when Capulet threatens to throw Juliet out if she doesn't marry Paris, her mother can't intervene. That would be good defense at a trial.
pohnpei397's profile pic

pohnpei397 | College Teacher | (Level 3) Distinguished Educator

Posted on

With both of them, you can just say that they are forced to do what they do by the demands of a patriarchal society.  Lady Capulet is not at fault -- she is just doing what her husband says.  In a patriarchal society, she has little choice.  Tybalt is just defending the honor and virtue of his kinswoman.  In a patriarchal society, a woman's chastity and her obedience to her father (when she is not yet married) are of paramount importance.  He is simply trying to prevent an outsider (Romeo) from potentially taking away Juliet's chastity and making/helping her disobey her father.

We’ve answered 318,991 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question