Criminal Justice Questions and Answers

Start Your Free Trial

Police have received a complaint from community residents about what the residents describe as a homeless man sleeping on a bench at a local park. As far as anyone knows, the man has not harmed anyone and does not appear to pose an immediate threat. There’s a local law prohibiting people from sleeping in public, and the fact that a complaint has been received suggest that residents are at least uncomfortable about the situation. Upon speaking with the man, police learned that he is simply very tired, has no permanent residence and no money for a motel room, and no other place to go. He prays for the police to give him a couple of hours to rest and promises that he will be on his way. How might a utilitarian approach resolve this issue? What moral duties might be relevant, how might and ethics of care approach this matter differently, and what tradeoff might allow for compromise and the accommodation of the needs of everyone?

A Utilitarian approach would attempt to balance the man's interests against those of the community. The police have a legal and moral duty to uphold the law, but also a moral duty not to exacerbate the man's suffering. The ethics of care emphasize the individual circumstances rather than the general moral principle, and would suggest a practical solution similar to Utilitarianism. This might involve finding the man a hostel or shelter, or another more secure place to sleep.

Expert Answers info

Colin Cavendish-Jones, Ph.D. eNotes educator | Certified Educator

briefcaseCollege Professor, Lawyer

bookM.A. from Oxford University

bookPh.D. from St. Andrews University

calendarEducator since 2019

write2,273 answers

starTop subjects are Literature, History, and Social Sciences

This situation exposes a weakness in Utlilitarian ethics. If Utilitarianism broadly advocates "the greatest good for the greatest number," how does one balance a slight good for a relatively large number of people against a much more substantial good for a small number?

In this case, we do not know how many people have complained about the man sleeping in the park, or how uncomfortable it makes them. It is therefore very...

(The entire section contains 237 words.)

Unlock This Answer Now

check Approved by eNotes Editorial