Please explain why the auteurist theory has become so important to film analysis, and what are some arguments against auteurist theory?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Auteurism, which was the dominant film theory beginning in the 1960s, had its origins a decade earlier with the French New Wave directors and expanded to those in other countries. The perspective was advanced by critics writing in the Cahiers du Cinéma journal. The theory was insightful in attributing to the director a role comparable to the author of a text, and in emphasizing the critical position of a singular, controlling force that included a vision or gaze.

Critics of this interpretation argue that it ignores other important figures who contribute to the film’s production, such as the writer and the onscreen presence of actors, especially famous stars. Perhaps more important, a re-evaluation of the function and practice of film, strongly influenced by postmodern literary theory, questions the stability of a singular understanding of any film, calling attention to the role of the audience. The rise of independent film, away from a studio system that privileged the director, has further eroded what is often called the “cult of the director.”

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In auteurist theory the film director is seen as the film's author, the one responsible for its quality and vision. This was important because it meant that critics could analyse films rather like a book, like a work of art. Alternatively, others argue that films are commercial products rather than works of art. In addition, they are the result of the efforts of a whole host of people: actors, cameramen, editors etc. rather than one person's work.

Audiences who go to see a film because of its director will respond differently to those who go to see a film because of its star. They are more likely to attempt to unpick its meaning, identify aspects of the director's style.

Posted on