Native Americans

Start Free Trial

Please compare and contrast the culture of the Aboriginal Australians with the Native Americans.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

This a very broad question- "Native Americans" is a deceptive term, alluding to the false depiction of indigenous peoples of North America as homogenous, rather than the diverse groups that actually existed. There is also the question of traditional culture versus modern reality, especially with movements to revive and adapt traditional culture happening in many indigenous groups. A Daily Herald article from 2011 claimed that there were 562 tribes in America, and that's after hundreds of years of colonization and the implementation of federal recognition program. There were a similar number of tribes in Australia pre-colonization, over 500 with diverse language and culture. So, any comparisons made have to recognize the broad scope of culture within the framework of indigenous tribes.

There are many similarities, however, in a broad sense. Nativism, or a religious connection to the earth, is a common theme. Nomadism and hunter-gatherer tribal life, while not the only expression of society, was also very common. Oral histories were also important, storytelling defines the traditional knowledge that both Aboriginal Australians and Native Americans use to tell their own stories. Kinship is very important in both societies as well, elders are highly respected and the family group is tightly knit.

It has been largely believed that Aboriginal Australians were as a whole entirely dependent on their environment, and practiced no agriculture. The lack of agriculture is a benchmark for nomadic societies, it is not considered possible to be sedentary without it. The Coast Salish people of Washington State practiced what is called aquaculture—"fish farms" with defined strategies to used rivers and coastlines as set sources of food. Although the view of Aboriginal peoples as lacking this societal phenomenon is being challenged, for now it can be seen as contrasting culture to Native Americans.

Aboriginal Australians also broadly practiced circumcision as an important rite of passage, along with incision of the urethra. This is not generally seen in North American tribes, and in fact subincision ties heavily into sacred rituals. So although there are many similarities with ideas of self and connection to spiritual and natural forces, for Aboriginal Australians and Native Americans these ideas manifest differently in physical senses.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

First, we should acknowledge that it is difficult to generalize about either native Australian or American peoples, who after all lived in a variety of different environments and developed very different cultures. Southeastern Indians, for instance, had far different lifestyles that were far different from those who lived on the Great Plains. But there are, perhaps, some grounds for comparison. 

First, most aboriginal Australians practiced hunting and gathering, which contributed to a very mobile society with a fairly egalitarian (equal) social structure. Not all Native Americans lived this way, but many did, at least at the time of European contact. The Micmacs, for instance, who lived in what is now Nova Scotia, collected shellfish, lobsters, fish, and sea mammals, a lifestyle which had much in common with people who lived along the southern coast of Australia and in Tasmania. By way of...

This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

contrast, many Native Americans lived in highly stratified societies. A person who lived in Cahokia, a city of up to 30,000 people, or any of the Aztec or Maya ceremonial centers would not have recognized many aspects of Australian life. No such societies existed in Australia, due to a lack of agriculture.

Another similarity, at least for some Indian peoples, would be religion. Many Native Americans, including some who lived in settled agricultural societies, held a view of religion that can be described as animist, much like Australians. They believed that spirits were immanent in nature, rather than inhabiting a separate realm from people. In this, both societies were quite different than Eurasian faiths, which tended to differentiate between the spiritual and the secular. People in the Americas and Australia saw dreams, in particular, as an important aspect of religious experience.

Finally, there are similarities between the political organizations of many aboriginal groups in both Australia and the Americas, especially North America. Aboriginal political units, called moeties by anthropologists, were organized along kinship lines, with members of clans interacting through commerce, warfare, and especially marriage. Native Americans were also organized along clan lines, even in some of the more complex societies. Interestingly, some aboriginal and Native American societies were matrilineal, meaning that property and status passed through the maternal line rather than the paternal (father's) line. Among southeastern Indians, this practice meant that a child's maternal uncle, rather than a father, would play a central role in raising him or her. Not all Indians or Australians adhered to this practice, however.

One more similarity, a modern one, should be noted: Both Aborigines and Native Americans were violently dispossessed of their lands, and subjected to concerted attempts to destroy their culture and force them to conform to western society. Both peoples continue to struggle to maintain old cultural forms as well as lands, especially sacred sites to this day. 

Source: Michael Leroy Oberg, Native America: A History (John Wiley & Sons, 2010)

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team