Over the years, have states gained more or less power relative to federal government? I know that the states have gained less power because the federal government makes decisions on more important matters such as taxes, war, than the states make. I am trying to look for good examples to describe to back it up.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The federal government has always had power in the realm of defense. Over the years, states have lost control over important issues such as education. The federal government's No Child Left Behind Act holds schools to a national standard and weakens state power over standards. States still have the right...

Unlock
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Start your 48-Hour Free Trial

The federal government has always had power in the realm of defense. Over the years, states have lost control over important issues such as education. The federal government's No Child Left Behind Act holds schools to a national standard and weakens state power over standards. States still have the right to decide how these standards are implemented, but the federal government's role in public education is one way that state power has eroded over the years. Another way is healthcare. The Affordable Healthcare Act created a rule in which everyone must have health insurance or pay a penalty at tax time. While states have implemented their own healthcare systems for the poor throughout the years, the federal government is now more involved in the healthcare industry than ever before. The federal government also collects more taxes than the state government to institute programs in various states. This takes power out of state legislatures and puts it in the hands of the federal government, who may or may not know how to best implement programs in those states.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In the past six years the Federal government has grown enormously. For information on how much the Federal government has grown with new agencies such as healthcare, etc., there is a wealth of information currently on the internet. Simply type in "How much has the federal government grown."

Below are some links:

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

You shouldn’t use issues of taxation and war to prove that the federal government has increased its powers over the years.  The Constitution always has given the federal government the power to make war, so that is not something that has changed over time.  Both states and the federal government have the power to tax, and that has not changed.  All that said, the federal government’s power has increased relative to the states’ powers.

The federal government’s power has really been growing most strongly since the Great Depression.  During that time, President Franklin D. Roosevelt proposed a variety of “New Deal” programs that gave more power to the federal government.  For example, they gave the federal government the power to affect the prices of agricultural products and the power to create a national pension system (Social Security).  Because of all these programs, the federal government came to have more powers and, more importantly, people started to expect the federal government to do a lot of things to help them.

The next big increase in federal power came in the 1960s.  The most important increase in this power came during the Civil Rights Movement.  During that time, the federal government took the power to regulate the ways that states treated their citizens.  The federal government got the power to ban racial segregation in all public accommodations (Civil Rights Act of 1964).  The federal government got the power to tell Southern states how to conduct their elections (Voting Rights Act of 1965).  This was also the time when President Johnson’s “Great Society” programs gave the federal government even more powers.  For example, it gave the federal government the power to give money to local groups and tell them how to spend it.  This bypassed the state governments and allowed the federal government to have more influence within the states.

Since then, some powers have been taken back and given to the states.  But for the most part the federal government has continued to take more power for itself.  It generally does this by telling states that they will not get federal funding if they do not follow certain rules.  The most prominent example of this in recent times is the “No Child Left Behind” law which gave the federal government a great deal of power over educational policy in the states.

In all of these ways, the power of the federal government has increased over time relative to the powers of the state governments.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team