If my statistical results do not fall within a "normal" curve, does that mean they are wrong? Why?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

I assume that you are asking about results that either lie outside a confidence interval, or results during a hypothesis test that lie in the critical region (tail.)

When creating a confidence interval we start with a point estimate for the population parameter we are interested in. For example, if we want to know the average height we might assume that the average from a random sample of sufficient size is a decent point estimate.

Understanding that the point estimate is not likely to exactly match the population parameter, we introduce an error term. This is added to and subtracted from the point estimate to create a confidence interval. The error term includes the standard error of the measurement, as well as a factor that is derived from the confidence level we want to achieve. (The larger the confidence, the larger the interval will be.)

If a secondary test gives results outside this confidence interval, is the result "wrong"? Not necessarily. Suppose the interval was created with a 95% confidence level. Thus we are 95% certain that the population parameter lies within the interval. One out of every twenty samples will have an estimate outside the interval. The true population parameter would lie outside the interval 5% of the time.

If we are doing a hypothesis test, in essence we are creating a confidence interval centered on the reported or accepted value of the parameter. Then we see if our sample statistic lies in that interval. If it does, we assume that the population parameter is as stated. If our sample statistic lies outside the interval (in the critical region), we have evidence to show that the given population parameter is incorrect.

In running a hypothesis test we run the risk of two types of error (assuming the samples are created correctly, etc...) A type I error is when we say that the purported parameter is incorrect, when it is actually correct. We have a lot of control over this type of error, as the probability of this type of error is equal to our confidence level. (I.e. at the 95% confidence level, the chance for a type I error is 5%.)

A type II error occurs when we fail to recognize an incorrect parameter. We can reduce the probability of this error by increasing the sample size and doing additional samples.

So when running a hypothesis test, the true result is not absolutely given. We only have probabilities to work with.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial Team