My debate topic is this:The United States should prevent all immigration into our country so that we move up the DTM stages. I have no idea how to start the opening statement; any suggestions? ...

My debate topic is this:The United States should prevent all immigration into our country so that we move up the DTM stages.

I have no idea how to start the opening statement; any suggestions? 

Thank you. 

Asked on by fancykat13

1 Answer | Add Yours

pohnpei397's profile pic

pohnpei397 | College Teacher | (Level 3) Distinguished Educator

Posted on

In a debate, an opening statement must set out the basics of your argument.  It must let the audience know what side you are taking in the debate and it must give a number of arguments for your side.  In order to write an opening statement, you must first know what you are going to say.

Although you do not state this explicitly, I take it that you have been assigned to support the statement given in your question.  If so, you definitely have the harder position.  You will need to argue that it is good for our country to move up through the levels of the demographic transition.  Let us look at three arguments that can be used to make this case, noting that I do not necessarily believe any of them.

First, you can argue that banning immigration will lead to more jobs for people who are already in this country.  You can argue that immigration increases the supply of labor and, therefore, drives down the wages that workers can demand.  It also creates more unemployment than would otherwise be the case.

Second, you can argue that a declining population will make the average American better-off.  You can argue that the money that we have will not need to be split up among as many people.  If we have fewer people, the money that, for example, the government has to spend on various programs can go to fewer people.  That will mean that each person who gets money will get more of it.

Finally, you can argue that a declining population will be good for the environment.  You can say that we will not keep needing more housing.  This will reduce the need for urban sprawl.  If this happens, there will be fewer cars driving and emitting greenhouse gasses.  Fewer people will mean less need for electricity.  It will mean less need for water.  All of these things will help to make our environment more sustainable.

So, to write your opening statement, write these arguments, and/or others that make similar points.  You should also have some sort of introduction.  You might say something like “Our world today is in grave danger due to environmental problems.  At the same time, our government is running out of money.  We can help solve both of these problems by banning all immigration to the United States.

1 reply Hide Replies

fancykat13's profile pic

fancykat13 | Student, Grade 8 | eNotes Newbie

Posted on

Hi, thanks for answering!

I'm actually on the opposing team but those are some really good points; I'll have to think of arguments against them. 

This is what I already have: 

High skilled immigrants come here to work and they help make advancements in technology and medication which can improve our health and the environment.

As baby boomers retire we need immigrants to come here and work to pay taxes and social security to help support our aging population and replace people retiring.  

Immigrant women have more rights here in the U.S than they had in their home country so most of them may choose to get an education instead of having kids.

Sources:

We’ve answered 318,982 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question