Are McMurtry's modern novels as good as his historical western fiction?

Expert Answers
thanatassa eNotes educator| Certified Educator

It’s difficult to predict whether you will enjoy his modern novels as much as his historical ones without knowing more about you. Both sets of neovels have been equally appreciated by critics, and both deal with western themes, so in a general sense they can be described as equally good. But the important question here isn’t some abstract sense of goodness, but what books you’d enjoy reading.

A way to decide whether you would enjoy them is to ask yourself what you enjoy about the historical works. If it’s the author’s style and approach, you probably would enjoy works set in other periods by the same author. If it’s the geographical setting, you’d probably enjoy most western novels. If your real interest is western history, you’d probably enjoy reading both fiction and non-fiction about the historical west by a variety of authors.

litteacher8 eNotes educator| Certified Educator
Generally, if you like an author's book you will like the others regardless of genre. Chances are you will enjoy the author's style and plotting, as well as uses of characterization. Even if you like historical fiction or westerns, you will likely still enjoy the novels.

Access hundreds of thousands of answers with a free trial.

Start Free Trial
Ask a Question