In Shakespeare's Julius Caesar, is Marc Antony a suitable successor for Julius Caesar?
Marc Antony is clearly not a comparable leader to Julius Caesar, a Roman leader of amazing physical and mental energy who possessed unmatched military power. Caesar's almost superhuman mix of energy, ability, and ambition have been superior to nearly every Roman leader after him. Here are reasons why Antony does not measure up to Caesar as a leader:
- Antony is duplicitous. In Act III, Scene 1, he sends his servant to ask Brutus, whom he professes love and honor, if he can speak to the Romans. He feigns great love and loyalty to Caesar by asking Brutus to kill him, as well. And, he falsely promises not to malign the conspirators if he is allowed to address the crowd. However, in his famous funeral oration. Antony's rhetoric completely turns the crowd against Brutus and the other conspirators by his repetition of the sentence,
Yet Brutus says he was ambitious;
And Brutus is an honorable man. (3.2.94-95)
- His motives for unseating Brutus as a leader are vindictive, and although he professes great love for Rome, he is extremely selfish as he is willing for a civil war to begin, a war which by definition is always devastasting to a country. "Now let it work: Mischief, thou art afoot" (3.3.262).
- He is treacherous and arrogant in his relationships with those for whom he professes affection. In Act IV the triumvirate acts much as the conspirators of the second act as they decide who will live and who will die. Marc Antony sells off his own nephew, Publius, because he is "a slight unmeritable man." He and Octavius argue as a result of Antony domineering posture.
I think Mark Antony is a capable successor for Julius Caesar because he shows that he is noble, respects others (as shown in Act 5, Scene 5, when he decides that Brutus should have a proper burial and was willing to murder someone who he thought would be a detriment to Rome), and makes tactical war strategies. Yet his strategies are not as complex and effective as Julius Caesar's, yet they work all the same. Out of the play, he would be the best choice as a successor for the throne.