Management can be thought as a process, a discipline, a human activity and a career. Do you agree?  Discuss.Management can be thought as a process, a discipline, a human activity and a career....

Management can be thought as a process, a discipline, a human activity and a career. Do you agree?  Discuss.

Management can be thought as a process, a discipline, a human activity and a career. Do you agree?  Discuss.

3 Answers | Add Yours

ask996's profile pic

ask996 | High School Teacher | (Level 1) Senior Educator

Posted on

If we define discipline as an important area of focus for the work environment then management is most definitely a discipline. Human empathy and understanding are integral in successfully mastering the management discipline, and one who can truly master it would find it a successful career choice.

sullymonster's profile pic

sullymonster | College Teacher | (Level 1) Educator Emeritus

Posted on

I think the best way to answer this question is to define each of the terms that you listed, and the compare them to term "management".  Lets start by defining "management":

"the act of overseeing or directing something"

Now, lets define "process":

"a particular course of action intended to achieve a result"

Clearly, if you are going to direct something - such as a group of people - then you are intending to achieve a result.  In order to achieve that resul, you will need a course of action.  So, the very idea of management is that it is a process.  The two are inextricably intertwined.

Next, we will define "discipline":

"a system of rules of conduct or method of practice"  OR "a branch of knowledge"

Both of these definitions lend themselves to what we have already said about management.  If you are going to direct something, there should be a system of rules in place so that you are both consistent and effective.  It is impossible to learn a sport without having a system of rules to follow - otherwise, it would be impossible to play.  There would be no way to know who wins - no one would agree upon what action equals a point.  The same is said in business - management is its own branch of knowledge because there is system of rules that has to be enacted, understood by all players, and followed.

A human activity sounds pretty straightforward - any activity that is commonly performed by humans.  Management is performed by humans in all areas of life.  Management of a household, a business, a school, a sport.  Even personal relationships require some form of management to keep things running smoothly.  As a species, we are heirarchial by nature, and have incorporated principles of management into our everyday lives.

Finally, a career.  A career is defined as:

"the particular occupation for which you are trained"

If we can agree that management is a discipline, something that has a branch of knowledge, then we can agree that it is something a person can be trained to do.  Looking at monster.com or at any job posting location, we can find numerous listings that come under the heading "management".  Individuals who are skilled at managing and directing many people and tasks simultaneously are well-suited to this career.

 

krishna-agrawala's profile pic

krishna-agrawala | College Teacher | (Level 3) Valedictorian

Posted on

Management is a human activity that is quite clear. After all, managers are humans and in the course of performing their duties they do engage in so many different activities. But calling management just an activity rather than a collection of activities would create a misleading picture of nature of management work.

Once we agree that management is a set of activities than agreeing that management is a process also becomes easy, because process is, after all a sequence of activities.

Also we have so many people pursuing the career of management. So it is very clear that management is a career.

Management is also a discipline, but to establish this we will need to look more closely at definition of a discipline and the nature of management methods.

A discipline implies a set of well established ways of performing a task or function. Though frequently managers have to rely on their individual judgement and inventiveness rather in carrying out their work, there are also many set patterns of work to guide the managers. The wide range of books available providing guidance on how to manage well, is a proof of existence of well established ways of performing management work, This makes it clear that management is a discipline also.

We’ve answered 318,911 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question