Is Jane's marriage with Rochester a happy ending in Jane Eyre? If not, why?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The ending, in which Jane and Rochester marry, is happy, if bittersweet.

It is bittersweet because Rochester has been disabled by the Thornfield fire, losing a hand and his eyesight. He is no longer the intimidating Byronic hero. Jane, too, has been through a series of sobering experiences.

It is, however, these maturing experiences that make it possible for Jane and Rochester to have a happy marriage. They marry on the basis of an honest foundation, for Bertha is dead. Rochester is disabled, but his disabilities allow the two to have a companionate marriage based on mutual equality. If Jane, the poor, quiet, dependent former governess had married Rochester when he was "whole," it would have been an unequal relationship, with Rochester in control. Now, Rochester is as dependent (or more) on Jane as she is on him.

They do have a happy marriage, filled with a deeper, sadder, more mature happiness than that perhaps experienced by frivolous young people in the first stages of passion. They appreciate each other all the more because they both have suffered. They have both known what it is like to feel lonely and despairing.

Brontë seems to be commenting on patriarchy in implying that a man needs to be disabled in some way for an equal marriage to take place.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Jane Eyre's marriage to Edward Rochester at the end of Charlotte Bronte's novel, Jane Eyre, is a romantic one, certainly.  For, earlier in the novel, Jane has so happily accepted Mr. Rochester's proposal of marriage only to learn that he is already married.  Refusing to compromise her principles, Jane leaves Mr. Rochester despite his pleas:

"Jane, do you mean to go one way in the world, and to let me go another?"

"I do."

"....Oh, Jane!  This is bitter. This--this is wicked.  It would not be wicked to love me."

"It would to obey you."

After Edward Rochester's rebirth by fire, however, in which he is blinded only to really see, Jane returns to Thornfield to love and cherish the man who now has paid for his sins.  For Jane, the ending is, indeed, happy since she can love Mr. Rochester without compromising her principles.  In addition, Jane's marriage to Mr. Rochester seems a reward for her earlier denials of his proposal as well as that of St. John Rivers.

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Is Jane's decision to marry Rochester a satisfactory ending to the novel?

Jane's decision to marry Mr. Rochester at the end of the novel makes a lot of sense given the events of the plot. Earlier in the novel, Jane and Mr. Rochester actually enter a church with the intent to marry. This first attempt at marriage is foiled because it is revealed that Mr. Rochester has a wife who still lives, but the ensuing conflict between Mr. Rochester and Jane reveals two characters separated only by circumstance. Their temporary split is not the result of any lack of romantic feeling. Rather, Jane chooses to leave Mr. Rochester because staying with him would violate her principles and consign her status to that of a mistress....

This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

The death of Mr. Rochester's wife then allows the reunion of Jane and Mr. Rochester.Jane's decision to marry Mr. Rochester is also deeply pleasing given her rejection of St. John. Jane realizes that a "marriage" to St. John would not result in her emotional satisfaction and would in fact signal the end of her hard-won autonomy. Additionally, Jane's childhood provides ample evidence that shows she keenly resents any form of injustice, and a departure to India with St. John would both betray her love for Mr. Rochester and her fervently held ideals. In choosing Mr. Rochester, Jane not only avoids betraying her own emotional sensibilities, she also espouses and confirms her own values.While this point is not as significant as the two former points, Jane's decision to marry Mr. Rochester also completes the reversal of fortunes. As a governess, Jane literally depends upon Mr. Rochester for her livelihood. Following her departure from Thornfield Hall, however, Jane comes into a substantial sum of money. In contrast, Mr. Rochester is virtually ruined by the destruction of Thornfield Hall. Jane's decision to then marry Mr. Rochester can be understood as the restoration of his fortune, the reunion of their love, and the renewal of both characters' moral being.

Last Updated by eNotes Editorial on