soldier crawling on hands and knees through a trench under a cloud of poisonous gas with dead soldiers in the foreground and background

Dulce et Decorum Est

by Wilfred Owen

Start Free Trial

Is "obscene as cancer" a metaphor?

"Obscene as cancer" is a form of metaphor called simile that compares two things using the words "like" or "as." Breathing in poison gas on the battlefield is here likened to a slow, painful cancer death.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

"Obscene as cancer"is a subset of metaphor called simile. A metaphor is a comparison, and a simile is a particular form of comparison that uses the words "like" or "as."

"Obscene as cancer" is a simile that compares the bloody "froth-corrupted lungs" coming up into a soldier's mouth to cancer. Both are a painful ways to die, and both are obscene because nobody should ever have to suffer that way or witness another person do so.

Owen uses this metaphor to emphasis his larger point that modern warfare is not heroic or glorious. It is not two armies of strong , muscled, sword-wielding soldiers in helmets and shining armor meeting to fight gloriously to defend the homeland. Instead, it consists of men who are bent over, "coughing like hags," shoeless with bloody feet, and exhausted, dragging frail and weary through another day.

There is nothing heroic about being caught unawares by a gas attack, breathing in the gas, and being tossed into a wagon to writhe in agony while bloody bubbles ("froth") form at your lips. Rather than a manly fight to the finish, dying in modern warfare is more like ending up helpless in a cancer ward.

This is an antiwar poem, and Owen is at pains to ensure that his audience understands that the story which has been told for thousands of years—that it is "sweet and fitting" to fight and die for one's country—is, as he puts it, a "lie."

Approved by eNotes Editorial Team