Question

In chapter 7 of Night by Elie Wiesel, describe the scene Elie witnesses between the father and son.

Accepted Answer

In chapter 7 of Night, Elie is in a crowded cattle car full of Jewish prisoners when the train stops in a German town. Several bystanders throw pieces of bread into the cattle car, and Elie witnesses the prisoners maul each other for the bread. Elie then watches an old man hide bread before he is attacked and killed by his own son. The son kills his father for the bread before several prisoners attack and kill him.

Answer

In chapter 7, Elie, his father, and the other Jewish prisoners are completely exhausted and malnourished after marching from Buna to Gleiwitz. The Nazi officers then force the prisoners into tightly cramped cattle cars as they begin their treacherous journey to Buchenwald. During their journey, the train comes to a halt in an empty field, and the Nazi officers instruct the prisoners to throw out the dead bodies, which creates additional room in the cattle cars. Along the journey, Elie and the other prisoners survive by eating snow, and some freeze from exposure to the harsh elements. After days and nights of constant travel with no food or protection from the elements, the train comes to a stop at a small German town and a worker throws a piece of bread into the cattle car.
Elie recalls the horrifying spectacle and vividly describes the battle that ensues between the starving prisoners as they fight and maul each other for scraps of food. German spectators observe the commotion and begin throwing more bread into the cattle cars. Elie then witnesses an old man attempt to hide a piece of bread in his shirt before he is suddenly attacked by his own son. The old man cries,

Meir, my little Meir! Don't you recognize me ... You're killing your father ... I have bread ... for you too ... for you too ...

Tragically, the son is intent on consuming the bread at all costs and kills his father for the scraps of food. Several other prisoners attack the son and end up killing him as well.

Answer

In the seventh chapter of this novel, Elie and his fellow prisoners board a train car following a two night long, freezing cold death march from Buna to Gleiwitz, as well as three additional days afterward in which no food or drink are distributed. Prior to boarding the train, the prisoners are given one ration of bread, which they consume along with spoonfuls of snow after spending the majority of an entire week with little or no food, despite having run almost 80 kilometers on foot.
The prisoners board the train in Poland and spend ten more days and nights with no food, while en route to Buchenwald concentration camp in Germany. While the train is stopped, a crowd of German spectators throw pieces of bread into train cars to watch the starving passengers fight one another for the chance to eat. Elie witnesses an old man who has hidden a piece of bread under his shirt being tackled and crushed by his son while attempting to take a bite. The man's heart-wrenching words to his son read as follows:

Meir. Meir, my boy! Don't you recognize me? I'm your father...you're hurting me...you're killing your father! I've got some bread...for you too...for you too...

After the son throws himself on top of the father to snatch the bread, he is tackled by other men who also want it, and at the end of the scene, the corpses of father and son lay side by side. This memory demonstrates the brutality and inhumanity that characterized many concentration camp victims, who were so near death that nothing seemed more important than survival alone.

Answer

The father and son scene in Chapter Seven of Night by Elie Wiesel shows the reader how absolutely terrible things have gotten for the prisoners. The Jews have been traveling by train, eating nothing but the snow which fell into their wagon. When they stopped in a German town, a worker threw a piece of bread into one of the train cars, and the men fought each other to the death for that bread while the Germans looked on as though they were at a circus. When a small piece of the bread landed inside the car Elie was in, he decided that he was not going to go after it, but he saw an elderly man crawling away and soon realized the man had a bit of the bread. As the man tried to eat it, his own son leaped upon him. The father cried out:

"'Meir, Meir, my boy! Don't you recognize me? I'm your father...you're hurting me...you're killing your father! I've got some bread...for you too...for you too...'"(Wiesel 96).

The son, like everyone else, was starving, and his father no longer mattered to him. All that mattered was food, and he killed his own father for that food. He, in turn, was killed by two other men, who beat him to death for that small piece of bread. This is what the Nazis had created.

Answer

The Jewish prisoners have been on-board a train, crammed in crowded cars, with no food for over 10 days.  They are starving and dying rapidly.  When the train stops briefly some workers throw some pieces of bread into the car.  Men immediately begin to fight over the bread.  The workers are amused and throw more bread. 
Elie sees an old man dragging himself toward the bread while holding another piece inside his shirt.  As he puts one piece in his mouth he is attacked by his son.  He screams "Meir, Meir, my boy! Don't you recognize me?"  His son continues beating him until he is dead and takes the bread from him.  After killing his father and getting the bread, he is also attacked and killed for bread.  You can read the exact details on page 68.

Night

In chapter 7 of Night by Elie Wiesel, describe the scene Elie witnesses between the father and son.

Expert Answers

Unlock This Answer Now

Related Questions

How does Elie Wiesel's father die in Chapter 8 of Night by Elie Wiesel?

In Elie Wiesel's Night, why was Elie's father struck by the gypsy?

How did Elie's father die in Night by Elie Wiesel?

How does Elie Wiesel describe his father in Night?

Describe the scene of leaving the ghetto in Night by Elie Wiesel.