In Trying to Find Chinatown, a Chinese-American street violinist named Ronnie and a Caucasian tourist named Benjamin share a complex and thought-provoking interaction. Benjamin asks Ronnie for directions to Chinatown, which sets off their heated discussion on racial and ethnic identities.
Benjamin assures Ronnie that he (a white male) understands Ronnie’s “righteous anger.” In his Asian-American studies class at the University of Wisconsin, Benjamin learned how Asians have been dominated by the white patriarchy; this social structure marginalizes minorities, discounts their achievements, and perpetuates offensive stereotypes. He enrolled in this class because
I wanted to explore my roots. After a lifetime of assimilation, I wanted to find out who I really am.
Ronnie, one the other hand, thinks that Benjamin is mocking him and points out that the tourist is white. The main reason Ronnie calls Benjamin “white” is Benjamin’s skin color. Ronnie exclaims, “Literally, look at your skin!” Grabbing Benjamin’s hand and holding it up for display, he exhorts, “You’re white!” Ben counters that he was adopted by Chinese-American parents (the Wongs), which makes him Asian American.
Ronnie scoffs at this justification with, “Even though they could put a picture of you in the dictionary next to the definition for WASP.” When Benjamin asserts that his race cannot be judged by his genetic heritage, Ronnie retorts, “If genes don’t determine race, what does?” and “Listen, you can’t just wake up and say, ‘Gee, I feel black today.’” To Ronnie, skin color is what determines a person’s identity.
On the positive side, Benjamin is trying to feel empathy for and a connection with Chinese-American people. On the negative side, Benjamin seems to lump all Chinese-Americans people together, as if they all share the same experiences. Ronnie asks Benjamin, “You think identity’s that simple? That you can wrap it all up in a neat package?”
See eNotes Ad-Free
Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.
Already a member? Log in here.