Mary, Kiki, and Roy are the only three people in Tinville. Mary is willing to pay $20 for the 5th unit of a public good, Kiki $15, and Roy $25. Government should produce the 5th unit of the public...

Mary, Kiki, and Roy are the only three people in Tinville. Mary is willing to pay $20 for the 5th unit of a public good, Kiki $15, and Roy $25. Government should produce the 5th unit of the public good if the marginal cost is: 

a. between $15 and $25. 

b. between $61 and $299. 

c. $300 or more. 

d. $60 or less.

Asked on by korikuma16

1 Answer | Add Yours

pohnpei397's profile pic

pohnpei397 | College Teacher | (Level 3) Distinguished Educator

Posted on

The first thing that you have to remember when answering this question is that the consumption of public goods is nonrivalrous.  That means that one person’s consumption of a public good does not reduce someone else’s consumption of that good.  This is important for this question because it means that all three of these people can consume the good.  Therefore, we have to look at the total benefit that the three of them would get from the production of the fifth unit of the public good.

If the good in this question were a private good, only one person would be able to consume the fifth unit that is produced.  Because it is a public good, all of them will be able to.  That means we have to add the prices that they would each be willing to pay to find out how much the fifth unit is worth to them as a group.  The sum of the prices they would pay is $60 ($25 + $20 + $15).  This means that the marginal benefit of producing the fifth unit is $60.

Efficiency in the production of public goods is achieved when the marginal cost is less than or equal to the marginal benefit of the last unit produced.  Therefore, it will be efficient for the government to produce the fifth unit so long as the price is not higher than $60.  In that case, D is the correct answer.

Please follow the link below for a more detailed explanation of this idea.

http://www.amosweb.com/cgi-bin/awb_nav.pl?s=wpd&c=dsp&k=public+goods:+efficiency

1 reply Hide Replies

korikuma16's profile pic

korikuma16 | eNotes Newbie

Posted on

Sir, I cannot thank you enough for helping me! I truly appreciate your detailed explanation, so clear, and your link was very helpful! I had not taken public and private goods into consideration when trying to solve the question, and now they helped me to understand how the solution was reached. Now I will be apply to apply this knowledge to similar questions on tomorrow's test, which is exactly what I was hoping to take away from someone's answer!

Thank you again, sir!

We’ve answered 318,957 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question