How does the speaker propose to solve the problem of impoverished children in "A Modest Proposal"?

2 Answers | Add Yours

kplhardison's profile pic

Karen P.L. Hardison | College Teacher | eNotes Employee

Posted on

In Jonathan Swift's satirical essay "A Modest Proposal" the speaker proposes that infants in Ireland, whose parents have no means of feeding them or clothing or housing them other than by begging (or stealing) and who are most often not children produced in a marriage, should, at the age of one year old, be sold as a food commodity.

He states that a 28-pound one-year-old should be able to feed a family for four nights. Furthermore, the skin could be sold as a separate commodity for gloves and such. He proposes that this would have benefit for the parents as they would have something of value to trade with and may perhaps then be able to pay their rent.

teachersage's profile pic

teachersage | (Level 2) Educator

Posted on

It's important to differentiate between the speaker (the narrator) of "A Modest Proposal" and Jonathan Swift, the author of the piece. The speaker, an individual focused solely on economics, spends the first paragraphs of the essay expressing in moving terms the plight of the many poor people in Ireland: the women in rags begging with their children clinging to them, the young men who are so hungry they die when they finally do get a job from the exertion of the work, the people who sell themselves into slavery in Barbados because the alternative is starvation. After having articulated their plight, the narrator then unveils his "modest" proposal: that poor women fatten their babies for a year and then sell them as a gourmet delicacy for rich people's tables. The narrator goes on to describe all the benefits that would accrue from this sale of babies, benefits that further outline the miserable conditions in which the poor currently live--men would be less likely to abuse their wives if the women were carrying or feeding a salable commodity, women would be less likely to abort their babies, Ireland's trade balance would improve, and the poor would have money. The narrator even proposes hunts for poor children at about age 12. 

Swift's purpose in writing this satire was to shock people into considering more humane solutions than cannibalism to the problem of Irish poverty--solutions he had proposed to deaf ears numerous times. The essay did succeed in shocking people and has remained a classic example of satire ever since. 

Sources:

We’ve answered 318,928 questions. We can answer yours, too.

Ask a question