How successful were the reform movements of the 1820s to 1840s?How successful were the reform movements of the 1820s to 1840s?

Expert Answers
mkoren eNotes educator| Certified Educator

The various reform movements of the 1820s-1840s had some successes. For example, the movement to improve education was successful. Horace Mann wanted to improve the curriculum in schools. He also had the school year lengthened to six months. Teachers were trained to be teachers as the Normal School was created to train teachers.

The anti-slavery movement had some successes. While slavery didn’t end throughout the country during this time period, anti-slavery societies in the North spread the message about ending slavery. William Lloyd Garrison began publishing a newspaper, called The Liberator, and founded the New England Anti-Slavery Society as well as the American Anti-Slavery Society. Slavery began to end in the North.

Dorothea Dix worked to help people who were in prison and who were mentally ill. She felt it was inappropriate to put mentally ill people in jail next to violent criminals. She also worked for improved conditions for prisoners.

The Temperance Movement wanted to ban alcohol. Many religious groups supported this. While there were some successes at the state level, such as in Maine in 1846, there was no nationwide ban during this time period.

pohnpei397 eNotes educator| Certified Educator

The answer to this varies widely because there were so many different kinds of reform movements going on during this time.  Different movements had very different levels of success.

For example, a major movement was the movement for the abolition of slavery.  You can argue about whether this movement succeded.  On the one hand, slavery was abolished after the Civil War.  On the other hand, most Northerners were not abolitionists and did not care that much about abolishing slavery.  Slavery would not have been abolished as soon if the South had not tried to secede.

Movement for educational reform, like those of Horace Mann, were more successful.  Mann's movement increased the amount of public schooling that was available, as well as the quality of teachers.  On the other hand, movements for such things as women's rights did not take off very quickly.  Women did not gain the right to vote for more than 70 years after the Seneca Falls Conference.

So the record of reform was very inconsistent and it is very difficult to say how much the reforms in general succeded.

brettd eNotes educator| Certified Educator

Many of the reforms were institutional in nature, that is, they were attempting to change and improve some fundamental rights and structures within America's government and society.  These are traditionally, and by nature, very difficult to change. 

So Dorothea Dix's attempt to reform the prison system into penitentiaries with the purpose of rehabilitating criminals was a major shift in policy.  It would take decades to determine whether or not it was successful, but there has been some attempt at rehabilitation ever since.

Abolitionists of the time sought another fundamental change in the law and society, one that was met with determined and sometimes violent resistance.  One could argue that actual abolition in 1865 would not have been possible without early activists "laying the groundwork" for that reform to become reality.

litteacher8 eNotes educator| Certified Educator
One of the biggest reform movements during this time was the push for universal suffrage. This included abolishing slavery and giving slaves rights, and giving women the right to vote. Ironically, slaves got the right to vote before women did. In addition to the prison and school reform mentioned above, there was also a growing temperance movement. Long before prohibition, there was a movement to abolish alcohol.